credit report copy request time barred debt credit report working tax credit a dsi mortgage credit repair kit tri bureau credit report fair credit reporting act 1970 form identity theft report online in florida free triple karma credit report log in online order free annual credit reports consumer report best travel credit card free credit report gov canada agency order free credit reports canada define federal fair credit reporting act credit lawyers who repair credit reports the only free credit report website how to clean up your credit report free every months free credit report online no credit card needed membership big three credit reporting bureaus payday loans online direct lenders only does mean my credit report account charged off negative information credit report view credit report online instantly how do i get a free credit report if i have been denied credit fcra order credit report canada new free credit report commercial 2010 band how to cancel free credit report .com sign all 3 free credit report and scores how to get something negative removed from your credit report what is credit muslim history in india legitimate place get credit report alaska usa federal credit union annual report credit reporting agencies disputes federal government annual free credit report credit report dispute letter experian free business my free credit report and score credit repair pain specialist charleston sc annual credit free report instant online payday loans no faxing all three credit reports and scores for free free tri merge credit report scores free government credit report and score order my credit report by mail how to remove charge offs from credit report credit report for free mortgage with credit score of 620 credit repair group garden grove california what does authorized user mean on credit report my 3 credit reports different long does serious delinquency stay your credit report best place to get credit report in canada how to get a paid collection item off a credit report can personal responsibility affect credit report how do youtube get your free credit report from equifax experian credit report request form family tax credit a free credit report vs free credit score commercials fair credit reporting act dispute how do i remove collections from my credit report how do i contest my credit report how much does it cost to run a credit report on a tenant get free credit report all 3 agencies equifax annual free credit report score collections credit report long credit bureau reports definition installment plan irs credit report credit cards for bad credit that report to credit bureaus can employer check credit report all in one credit report can company run credit report without permission credit report without membership information death credit reporting agency free annual free credit report cleaning credit report order free credit report equifax too many credit inquiries on credit report get all three credit bureau reports bankruptcy report to creditors how to cancel my credit report account read credit report payment history prepaid debit cards that report to credit agencies one time credit report and fico score how to fix your bad credit report view credit report for free without credit card what is a consumer statement on a credit report there any way actually get free credit report how to get my credit score to 800 free credit report and score band debt collection reporting to credit bureau credit repair certification lpn programs in tampa florida free credit report equifax experian transunion get free credit report canada online no credit card the credit report loophole easy credit professional computer repair tool kit free annual credit report for experian free credit report 360 credit card settlement effect on credit report does capital one report credit limits 2010 government official credit report site free credit report without free trial long does take repair credit report been denied credit free report entitled consumer credit report protection act where to get a free credit report annually dispute something on credit report credit report and background check for employment should i report stolen credit card to police find out what;s your credit report three credit report score how to dispute inaccuracies on credit report transunion 3in1 credit report experian free credit report number how to fix credit report how often are you entitled to receive a free copy of your credit report collection debt credit report obtain credit report for free bank of america credit reporting department free credit report gov uk pay how do you order a free credit report how to remove collections from credit report can small business report credit bureau ordering credit reports for tenants consumer credit protection act south africa add rental history credit report access credit report online is chexsystems a credit reporting agency credit cards reporting to credit bureau free credit scores reports no credit card most accurate free credit report triple score credit report free td bank report lost credit card hidden credit repair farmville secrets ebook top three credit report agencies top ten reporting bad credit agencies free report uk equifax low credit understanding my credit report best place for free credit reports how do i order a credit report how do i get all three credit reports free citi credit card report stolen dun bradstreet credit reports credit reports computed civil judgement credit report remove long does take eviction show your credit report credit report 3 bureaus one time totally free credit report once a year consumer cheap personal loan credit union how can i get a copy of my credit report for free three credit report one is it possible to remove charge off from credit report how to remove incorrect information from credit report credit report repair forms how to request my credit report by mail view credit report transunion again free 3 bureau credit report no credit card rent how to get free credit report once a year financial how to freeze your credit report online when can a chapter 7 bankruptcy be removed from credit report credit suisse report india does negative information fall off credit report what do lenders see on my credit report review annual credit report inaccurate credit reporting lawsuit is my credit score hurt when i check my credit report the real free credit report annual sovereign bank credit report what is a derogatory public record on a credit report credit report date last activity how to run a credit report on a potential renter credit report monitoring reviews does kd mean experian credit report credit rating reports canada fair credit reporting act consumer report employment experian credit reporting company annual credit report form pdf how does one really get your free credit report write credit report personal statement who can request a credit report how do i remove late payments from my credit report lexisnexis fair credit reporting act consumer debt report credit matters what is a tax lien on credit report access annual credit report outside us credit report official site fair credit reporting act dispute procedures how to cancel free credit report com service eviction credit report credit reports equifax transunion dispute letter for credit report sample credit reporting agencies dispute address how to remove a collection agency from your credit report one time free credit report check free credit report on tenants yearly credit report 2012 free copy your free once year credit report credit report services for landlords paid collection on credit report free us gov credit report legit guaranteed money loans online why was the fair credit reporting act of 1970 created do credit reporting agencies get their information average credit good credit score for mortgage loan how can i get a public record off my credit report do landlords check credit reports credit repair scam through claim of id theft cash advance today orem utah newspaper free credit report mn how do you get a credit report on someone where is the free credit report annual when do defaults get removed from credit report view credit report without credit card how do i get a free credit card report how often can i get free credit report short sale vs foreclosure credit report definition free consumer reports fair credit reporting act wells fargo customer free credit report equifax answers correct credit report errors copy of my credit report for free how to cancel free credit report account how to get bad credit removed from your report foreclosure how long on credit report get free credit report united states get free credit report landlord remove charge off from credit report how to update credit report after bankruptcy most accurate credit report foreclosure credit report after bankruptcy best credit reporting agency for landlords free us credit report government long will chapter 13 my credit report dispute credit report items online how to obtain my credit reports nco national credit reporting services dispute charge offs your credit report how can i check on my deceased mother;s credit report how to find my credit report for free how long to clear credit report after paying collection agency credit report addresses dispute credit report monitoring companies check my credit score free charge write off bad debt credit report what are the lyrics to the free credit report commercial band plays free credit report commercials free credit report every year every 12 months soft pull credit report how long can a collection account stay on your credit report credit reporting agency fair credit reporting act under section address for equifax credit reporting agency free credit report georgia equifax does citibank report all 3 credit bureaus phone number for annual credit report ftc credit report disclosure free annual who are the guys in the free credit report commercial saw credit score reports government christian credit repair companies in texas free credit reports bureaus better credit report how long does it take to rebuild my credit score any real free credit reports how long does it take for a short sale to show up on your credit report report bad credit card company credit rating scale chart report lost stolen american express credit card how do i get charge offs removed from credit report experian credit report free copy car finance with bad credit history uk credit help report can you sue for wrong information on credit report credit reporting time limit uk give yourself some credit understanding your credit report free full credit report no credit card equifax credit reports codes transunion free credit report california citi credit reporting department how to cancel your free credit report .com account credit report errors pirg credit credit free vin history report canada what is the free credit report song all 3 credit reports fico score how to free credit reports online instantly how to remove paid-off collection accounts from credit report free credit report no trial how to remove a default judgement from credit report where can i get my credit report and score fair credit reporting act form disclosure credit report america phone number how to remove disputes from credit report get free credit report online without using credit card credit report clark howard 360 free credit report where can i get free credit report yahoo most current credit report how do you check your credit report canada best place get your report free annual credit i want to check my how do i check my credit report for free free credit check report uk cancel mni credit report services name band free credit report commercial how to get free credit report by mail first report on the public credit alexander hamilton has best report service credit score bankruptcy dismissal and credit report consumer credit reports for businesses how long does a judgement stay on my credit report where do i get my free annual credit report and score all three credit score report first community credit union credit report obtaining a free report in canada credit rating cease and desist letter to creditors template kd on credit report what does that mean teachers federal credit union credit report credit card company doesn;t report credit limit remove old debt off credit report federal reserve se july 2011 report on consumer credit free credit report irs gov phone numbers telephone numbers get copy your credit report canada bad credit loan companies in wv my credit report score free false information on credit report removal bad debt credit report credit report federal trade commision free credit reports in georgia 3 bureau credit reports scores most reliable credit reports best cashback credit cards consumer reports phone numbers for credit report companies what does government mandated mean free annual credit report reporting free rental history check credit report 3 credit scores report free credit report canada online equifax what is the federal fair credit reporting act fcra paying debt not on credit report secured credit card reports monthly does derogatory status mean credit report security freeze on equifax credit report natwest credit card protection free credit report equifax no credit card obtaining credit report online run a credit report on a tenant certified credit report payday loan copies my credit reports how to get a medical collection off your credit report advance america cash advance locations fl credit report 100 word statement credit report free us government free credit report equifax canada online report illegal credit card fees how to remove charge off items from credit report authorization to obtain credit report form free credit report how to cancel annual federal credit report how to remove negative accounts from my credit report consumer credit reports small business how to obtain a credit report on someone else credit report dispute samples annual credit report login transunion illegal pull someone;s credit report free credit report through federal government can free credit report transunion i get my how do you get a bad credit rating uk credit report lock out experian free credit report info fcr.com denied credit report experian how do i read an equifax credit report free credit commercial club report check plus score and experian credit report can i run a credit report on my tenant credit annual reports for canadian companies sample credit report equifax 3 major credit reporting bureaus free report 3 bureau annual report credit scores get a credit report canada tenant credit reports massachusetts ny state tax lien on credit report free credit report old band back annual credit report request form spanish free credit report.com commercials actors credit score reporting rules annual credit report government free credit report yearly government get my free credit report free getting your how to get your credit score up fast my official free credit report ftc free report score personal solutions credit remove dismissed chapter 13 credit report get my yearly credit report free remove credit inquiries credit report define consumer consumer credit reporting reform act 1996 annual free credit reports where to get free credit report annually get one time free credit report is it safe to order a credit report online my free business credit report free credit report gov us order csc credit report am best credit rating free credit reports canada for real credit report usa pdf pull credit report for tenant free credit report check no credit card free credit report forums $500 cash advance with no credit check how do i pull a credit report on a tenant view your credit report free experian my credit file veda login where can i order my free credit report consumer credit market report 2011 court judgment credit report credit report has wrong address what are the major provisions of the fair credit reporting act free credit report dot com band wiki capital one canada rebuild your credit fair credit report act authorization equifax credit report fico score long term bad credit loans direct lender sample letters to remove inquiries from credit report free online credit report no credit card required instant online payday loans lenders definition of a credit reporting agency fair credit reporting act information furnishers who are the three credit reporting agencies in the u.s credit suisse ag annual report 2008 best place get all three credit reports scores free true credit report equifax how to read an equifax 5.0 credit report free copies my credit reports how do i contest something on my credit report apply for payday loan online directly from lender free annual credit report ftc civil claim judgment credit report what is a charge off on a credit report order a credit report on someone does capital one credit report transunion credit report usa credit report and the rest is history meaning free credit report 3 reporting agencies information companies asking for credit report does a credit report include credit score request credit report experian what does charged off mean on my credit report do utility companies report to credit bureaus mailing address transunion credit reporting agency national consumer law center fair credit reporting transunion vs equifax fico score free credit report agency under fair credit reporting act free credit report no card information free credit reports com 11 credit bureau report and scores how to understand credit report does checking your own credit report affect your score how do you get a credit report on a person what does kd stand for on your credit report free credit report guy names three credit reporting agencies can get credit report my bank equifax credit report how to read free credit report for tenants credit report company addresses do jobs need credit report how to run credit report on someone else the fair credit reporting act purpose is triple credit report with score create new credit report unauthorized hard inquiry credit report equifax credit report phone number canada checking credit report renters view free credit report online certified reporting credit score gov free credit report one a year free credit report experian credit report uk login free credit report.com cell phone song and lyrics can i get a free credit report once a year best place get annual credit report free experian credit report review how to update info on your credit report remove incorrect address my credit report how to remove a judgement off your credit report my credit report without signing up membership pull credit reports business american express free credit report and score free credit report guys back experian smart business credit reports canada credit report experian credit report score rating how can i get a dispute credit report for experian reporting tenant debt credit bureaus cancel true credit report com obtaining a how to get my credit report for free medical collections credit report companies fix credit reports official government free annual credit report consumers how long do negative items stay on my credit report get my free credit report law does chase sapphire report credit limit should i dispute everything on credit report cma global sovereign credit risk report q1 2011 fair credit reporting act 2010 text request your free annual credit report canada credit report monthly monitoring clean my credit report mailing addresses for credit report companies
Home Biz of Baseball - Interviews Interview - Janet Marie Smith - Planning & Development

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 661 guests online

Atom RSS

Interview - Janet Marie Smith - Planning & Development PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 16
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Tuesday, 05 October 2004 12:00

Janet Marie SmithTurner Field. Camden Yards. Fenway Park. Janet Marie Smith has been involved in the planning and development of all three.

The interview covers views on how stadium development should be a synergy of the environments they reside in, the differences between the Braves, Orioles, and now the Red Sox has been, what makes a ballpark "classic", and renovating, yet not diminishing Fenway Park's historic value.


 
If there needed to be one word to describe Janet Marie Smith, maybe the word to use would be “versatile.”

The three major MLB facilities that she has played a part in planning and developing could not be more different or more visible.

She has served as President of Turner Sports and Entertainment Development, a division of Turner Broadcasting System, and was Vice President of Planning and Development for the Atlanta Braves baseball team. During her tenure there, she had the unique job of the design and conversion of Atlanta’s 1996 Olympic Stadium into Turner Field, the home of the Braves.

From 1989 – 1994, Ms. Smith was the Baltimore Orioles’ Vice President for Planning and Development of Oriole Park at Camden Yards – the gold standard to which all modern ballparks are compared.

And now, she takes on probably one of the most difficult planning and development jobs in MLB – changing a shrine.

Smith now serves as Vice President of Planning and Development for the Boston Red Sox, which began the 2002 baseball season under new ownership. She is charged with evaluating options to renovate the home of the Red Sox. The last series of renovations to the park came in the ‘80s. The task of expanding Fenway while retaining its historic charm must be daunting.

We last caught up with Ms. Smith just before the Red Sox won the 2004 World Series. Given the win the team and facility will be more popular than ever. Rushing to catch a plane to St. Louis for Game 4 when we last talked, she was dealing with the request to expand Fenway seating by another 10% (see sidebar ) and was the only front office member not scheduled to be in St. Louis for a Game 3.

In this interview Smith touches on a variety of subjects ranging from the differences among the 3 major baseball facilities she has been involved in to what ballparks she thinks might become “classic”. She talks about how planning a ballpark has to be done hand-in-hand with the host community and why making ballparks odd for oddity sake is, “trying to be whimsical for the sake of the folly of it.” - Maury Brown


BizBall: Is ballpark design more a reflection of the club's wishes/specs/requirements or the architect's design/inspiration/creativity?

JMS: Well, that’s a tough question.

I think that baseball parks have historically been most interesting when they are architecturally done with a little "a", when they have been designed by their surroundings, when they are a product of the environment they’re in, and the region; less so then when they have been thought of as an architectural edifice that needs to make a statement.

Red Sox look to expand Fenway by 10%

Just before we went to publication for this interview, the Red Sox made a formal request to the Boston Landmarks Commission to make two changes to Fenway to try to maximize the venue in terms of seating capacity, and to allow the new World Series Champions some well deserved new space in the Clubhouse.

The expansion would add roughly 10% to Fenway's current capacity increasing from 36,298 to 39,928. As Janet Marie Smith explains, this would be done by removing the 4 rows of roof-box seating in the "406 Club", raising the roof line from 70' to 80' from street level, and replacing the 4 rows of roof-box seats that were removed, with 8 new rows. In addition, Fenway's well-worn roof will replaced.

To help with the congestion associated with the additional seating, the circulation area behind the seating will be expanded to allow for approx. 200 standing room patrons as well.

To view the proposed expansion designs, please access these 2 PDF documents provided by the Red Sox organization.

And, I’m not at all suggesting that architects aren’t important in ballpark design, just saying that I think that the more successful ones are the ones, where architects have created a setting for the games to be played and the fans to celebrate it, and not necessarily look to make their own statement about trends and designs, or their own mark on the building.

Bizball: You’ve worked for three different MLB organizations. What were some things that were different about the Orioles, Braves, and Red Sox that you had to take into consideration?


JMS: Well, they all couldn’t be more different in their own way, and yet there is some commonality. It’s interesting to me that they are more different than alike.

Their commonality is the distance between the baselines. The Orioles were looking to build an urban ballpark, one that had modern amenities but that was the first in an effort, I should say the first effort was the Royals Stadium in Kansas City is, I think, rightfully the first. But they were looking to build on this notion of a single stadium for baseball and a single stadium for football and design something that unlike Kansas City took in their surroundings and devoted to being a part of the city environment. I think the Oriole’s commitment to that, particularly Lucchino’s commitment to that is best evidenced by not only agreeing to a downtown location but saving the warehouse, working within the site that had very little parking and no parking at all a full 50% of the frontage. Those were actions that backed up the rhetoric very early on.

The Braves had a completely different set of circumstances. They had been wanting a new single purpose park for years and years and had assumed they would have to go outside of Atlanta to find the financial ability of a community to help fund one and then the Olympics came along and all of a sudden there was this window of opportunity to get a park that was completely debt free. No one owed any money on it when the games were over, as long as they were willing to design it as an Olympic Stadium first and then convert it to baseball. So the challenges there were a lot less about knitting it into the environment and rather time to work within the Olympic constraints and make it work for baseball afterwards. And the site was selected solely because it was already owned by the city and there were no constraints to moving forward. The construction of a deadline that the city and our nation couldn’t bear the thought of missing.

Fenway Park, of course, is a completely different animal in that it’s the first serious attempt to preserve one of the older ballparks. Tiger stadium and Comisky were torn down late enough in their lives that people had, historic preservation had developed a foothold in America. There was a lot of evidence that historic rehab could work and yet no one had ever been willing to apply it to a sports venue and so with only two ball parks left from that era and the club had been committed to Fenway for a long time and the Red Sox again under the direction of Larry Lucchino had been particularly interested in trying to make certain that their stewardship of Fenway Park includes a thoughtful renovation with the ability to have it work economically going forward.

BizBall: At this stage in history, Oriole Park at Camden Yards is viewed as the gold standard for new park development. If plagiarism is the highest form of flattery, then surely you must be flattered, as it’s been copied in one form or another since being built. When did you realize that Camden was going to be something more than just a new ballpark?

JMS: That’s nice to hear.

BizBall: If plagiarism is the highest form of flattery, then surely you must be flattered, as it’s been copied in one form or another since being built. When did you realize that Camden was going to be something more than just a new ballpark?

JMS: I think that as it was under construction, we began to realize that the national media was watching it. And initially that wasn’t a huge surprise being as close to Washington as Baltimore is; we’re celebrating the fact that we had so many fans from DC. It was as much as Camden Yards made the Orioles a stable franchise so that the commitment to regionalizing the fan base and so we were always thrilled when we got media that was beyond Baltimore; we’d stop in New York, Pennsylvania and down to Washington DC and Richmond.

I think it was probably along about ‘90 or ‘91 that we began to realize that the simple mantra that Larry Lucchino had us all hyped for so many years, an old fashion ballpark with modern amenities was one that had caught on, and perhaps new Comisky which had a similar sound bite but had not risen to anything that caused much celebration probably made us work harder to make certain that we were adhering to the standards that we had set for ourselves of capturing the spirit of an old ballpark. But it was probably, I think it was probably that, the national media focusing on it that made us realize that maybe we were onto something that would have a greater meaning through out the country than just the stadium, the ballpark we were looking to build.

BizBall: Which of the post-Camden Yard parks do you feel will become classic "destination" parks like Wrigley, Fenway, and now, Camden Yards?

JMS: I think Pac Bell in San Francisco, Petco in San Diego and Coors Field in Denver all had that potential and Jacob’s, I guess, in Cleveland I would put in that category.

Much of my admiration for them has to do with the neighborhoods they chose to be in, because Camden Yards wouldn’t be the same if it had been built out on the Beltway and it’s not Pac Bell anymore, it wouldn’t be the same if it had been inland. And I think Jacob’s Field which redefined downtown Cleveland. I think those are the parks that stand the chance to be most successful and I think the success is derived, back to your original question, sort of less from the ballpark itself; how many club seats and how many suites, is it painted white, is it painted green? It’s capturing the totality of what fans go to, I am a real believer that if fans were only interested in the outcome of the nine innings that there are a lot of other ways to stay tuned to your favorite team. It’s the experience of being at the ballpark the camaraderie of being with other people that make it an outing and much more than just a game.

BizBall: As an architect, what allows you to make decisions that create a stadium that becomes more than just a place where a ballgame occurs? What allows a stadium to take on a place of being within a given city?

JMS: Well I think one thing that for me personally helps is I don’t have to act as the architect. I’ve always worked with really good architects who could devote all the energy it took to the problem solving of putting a building together and devote my energies in trying to figure out what does it want to be. How do you go out and listen to the fans and come back with input from them? How do you absorb the city around it and try and pick up on the nuances of the neighborhood? How do you understand the traffic patterns and focus on what makes those work, so that no matter how cute, nostalgic or historic your ballpark, if you can’t get there, its not any fun to go.

So I think it is important, I guess, for my own role. I think of it as not… obviously I don’t think of myself as being the architect, but rather as sort of the, almost like a film director. How do you direct all these consultants and all of this input and try and put together and edit it in a way, movies are a great analogy, so that you are putting something out for people to enjoy because it becomes the setting for something really wonderful. Baseball is a wonderful game but it is the strategy and intrigue of the game that requires the setting that as equally as interesting.

BizBall: On the other side of the Camden Yards coin, is the comment by some stadium design critics that the retro ballpark, ala Camden Yards, is being emulated to the point of making the design blasé. Is there a point where the same design takes on too much of a good thing?

JMS: Well, I am not a fan of the term retro ballpark by any means and I could tell you when we were doing Camden Yards, I would bristle on the occasions when that term was used. Canden YardsWe never felt that Camden was a retro ballpark. We were trying to design a ballpark that like the older ballparks was a single purpose park with a playing field that wasn’t contorted to be perfectly symmetrical but was responsive to the surroundings. We were looking for, instead of building materials, a building construction type and the steel trusses that made sense for the Baltimore setting. We wanted that building to be contextual. We weren’t looking to do a retro ballpark. And I suspect that every team that came after us can honestly say something similar and so I completely disagree with that. I think making a ballpark contextual is a noble goal and then one can measure how well you succeeded.


BizBall: You now are in the midst of working on one of baseball’s most revered facilities in Fenway Park.

JMS: A job I take very seriously.

BizBall: As I imagine so.

The park has undeniable idiosyncrasies, such as the Green Monster, doorways on to the field, and the Devil’s Triangle in centerfield – all by-products of the cramped site location. Recently, ballpark design seems to have latched on to this type of quirkiness and tries to artificially incorporate it into  new ballparks. Is there a point where ballparks can become forcefully odd just for the sake of being odd?

JMS: Yeah, I do think so.

That’s where I do agree.

I think cute for the sake of cute is never a good thing. And there is a fine line between being contextual and being, trying to be whimsical for the sake of the folly of it. And I do think there’s a point where that’s not as meaningful.

BizBall: How difficult has it been to try and squeeze everything out of Fenway as you can, and still retain its historic qualities?

JMS: Well, it’s tough but I appreciate the constraints. Sometimes it’s easier to work within constraints than it is a clean slate. So I don’t know that it’s enormously difficult, particularly since the ownership values Fenway first and foremost. So one of the things I have a huge appreciation for John Henry and Tom Werner and Larry Lucchino on, they are not coming to Fenway and saying well, the perfect ballpark in the New England region should have 80 private suites and 5000 club seats and be a total capacity of 41,000.

How do we get that out of Fenway? They are coming from the opposite door and saying we have a ballpark that is the oldest in the major leagues, the most beloved, that has been threatened for 15 years, that we have a chance to say, and what can we do to save it? Try and recognize that we need to make more money in this ballpark in order to field a competitive team. But the last thing we want to do is layer so much onto it that it doesn’t feel like Fenway.

Now how do you figure out how elastic it can actually be? And the answer is Fenway is pretty elastic.

You know, it went through a radical transformation between 1911 and 1934 and it went through another radical transformation when they added, what started out as a football press box and grew into all these suites on the top. They added, they made another radical change with the 406 Club, and yet it’s still Fenway.So I think what I’ve heard thus far in the three years that I worked for Larry and John and Tom is that nothing they do is going to be as radical as what’s gone on before. And if anything they tried to turn back the hands of time, where appropriate, in terms of restoring the facades, taking down that big green wall that caused you to completely lose the pyramid shape of the bleachers. They’ve respected Fenway for Fenway and have tried where they could to add things that didn’t seem to destroy its original character.

BizBall: You know there wasn’t a lot of changes that went on in the previous past before Tom Werner, John Henry, and Larry Lucchino -- before the current ownership came along. Couldn’t most of the changes that your making to Fenway have been done years ago if previous ownership understood what a treasure Fenway was and wasn’t so focused on getting a new ballpark?

JMS: Well, I think they could have but sometimes things need to happen in due course. You know, I imagine if you kind of weaved together the questions you’ve asked, that the goal to replace Fenway came at a point in time when every ballpark was aiming for 45-50,000 seats.

It came at a time before the nostalgia for the old ballparks was as keen as it is today.

It came before the bloom was off the rose for some of the new ballparks and we’ve seen even the most successful of them that, you can only have a sellout season so many years in a row.

And then you better field a competitive team, and you better keep your ballpark fresh, and you better reach out to fans and make certain you’re part of the menu of choices that they make. And so the answer is physically could they have done it, absolutely. But could you have seen that without the crystal ball that we have? Probably not.

BizBall: Camden Yards opened up with a capacity of about 48,000, which is somewhat larger than the parks opened in the past four years. What’s the practical maximum capacity for a ballpark, before adding more seats destroys the feeling of intimacy that fans seem to cherish?

JMS: Well, I guess it depends on where you start.

You fingered exactly the thing that we’ve been watching, which is the trend getting smaller and smaller and I think some of that has to do with intimacy and some of it has to do with just good selling practices. That it’s better to have people feel like they need to buy early and often then to feel like they can wait to see how the team does before they commit to their summer games.

I don’t know that there’s a magic answer.

I don’t think Coors or Camden feel excessively large, although there is just a magic to Fenway that can’t be replicated. Even the newer parks like Petco and Pittsburgh that have been built are closer to 40 than 50 [thousand] they still have incorporated all of the presumed rules of having wide tread width, wide seat width, cross aisles for venders to pass, without obstructing views.

Of course, all the rules that come with ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act), frequent number of aisles in order to be able to sell a certain number of box seats and not having fans stepping over 20 people. And a construction methodology that says lets not have any columns, lets pull the upper deck far enough back that you can see the trajectory of the ball. If you do all of those things, even if you only put in 30,000 seats, you’re 1½ times as large as Fenway is, because Fenway and Wrigley were built to completely different set of standards.

It does make me think sometimes that all of these wonderful things that we’ve done for our own personal creature comfort had had a net loss to the communal comfort of being in a ballpark.

I’ll use Yankee Stadium as an example because it was redone in the 70’s you know.

Their cross aisles are designed so that if you’re sitting behind a cross aisle you better be on your feet cause you can’t see what’s going on as a result. There is an energy to Yankee Stadium that you’re not going to find someplace that’s designed it for all these sort of wonderful things that allow you to stay there with your newspaper and never be disturbed.

BizBall: The Red Sox recently held a Jimmy Buffet concert in Fenway. In years past, that would have been deemed probably unthinkable, but modern turf and drainage systems now make it possible to use baseball fields for other events without killing the grass. How many more such events are likely to come in the future in Fenway? Are other baseball teams looking into staging summer concerts as well?

JMS: I think a couple of things have happened.

The drainage on the playing field is better, the turf is, and we won’t have it, make it, almost like a, not a natural thing. The kind of covering they put on the playing field to protect from the chairs is more sophisticated. It now can breathe, so it doesn’t smother the grass during Fenway Parkthe time it’s down. So everything has advanced technologically. For Fenway, I believe that our fans were willing to allow us to have the Jimmy Buffet concert this year and Bruce Springsteen last year in part realizing that one of the trade offs of keeping Fenway, which only holds 36,000 people and is by far the smallest ballpark in the major leagues, that we needed to find other things that we could do there to help on the revenue side.

And this -- two concerts a year --seems I think fairly modest as long as we’re observing the neighborhood’s request for ending early, not having sound checks in the middle of the night, you know, doing things that simply are neighborly. And I suspect you’ll see more teams doing that if they can control it and I do think that there is a fear that in a municipal owned ballparks that if the teams weren’t able to control it I think teams are often fearful that something would be done, that no one couldn’t be as sensitive as they could, returning it to baseball ready conditions.

BizBall: What are the important differences between designing a football stadium versus a ballpark? When one drives by Ravens Stadium in Baltimore, one is struck by its enormous size and lack of grace compared to Camden Yards, which looks small and homey by comparison.

JMS: Well, I think that clearly the ownership made a big difference in Camden Yards. I don’t want to suggest that the Ravens didn’t care as much about their venue, but I suspect they cared, just by looking at it, I would suspect that they cared more about things that you could quantify that made it terrific as an experience being inside the park, the stadium and looking at the game.

I think baseball is a little more sensitive, even if there is not the tradition of tailgating and all those kinds of things that come with football. Baseball is a little more sensitive to just the total ambiance and the realization that in a game where you don’t have a fast pace necessarily and you have a long season, that with 81 games a year and nine inning games that can sometimes stretch to four hours that the setting is important. Just checking off the quantitative things aren’t going to make it a terrific experience.

Bizball: Tiger Stadium is sitting abandoned in Detroit and will probably be torn down as soon as there is a chance to use the property for commercial development. Many plans have been discussed to renovate the historic park. Is that really practical? Has any old ballpark ever been successfully renovated, and if not, why?

JMS: To my knowledge, there has never been a serious effort to renovate a stadium to an alternate use.

That is too bad because in recent years we have seen facilities torn down like Memorial Stadium in Baltimore and Atlanta Fulton County Stadium in Atlanta. Just because it’s reached the end of its presumed economic life I don’t think means it has reached the end of its structural life.

In Atlanta, there was a research done into making the 1960's stadium into parking, but the effort came to late to really develop any serious attention.

The same was true, even more sadly in Baltimore.

The vintage 1930's Memorial Stadium was kept for 10 years after the Orioles moved to Camden Yards as home to the eventual Ravens NFL team while their new stadium was under construction. During those years, several preservationists and developers put in proposals to reuse the structure for a range of uses including housing and university space.

Unfortunately, there was not the political will to try something new, and we lost one of the biggest monuments of that architectural era.

It would be so nice for Detroit to have a serious search into alternate uses for Tiger Stadium. And frankly, now that there are but few of the "cookie cutter, donut parks" it would be nice to see at least one spared the wreaking ball. While not great places to watch games, the architectural detail of St. Louis' Busch Stadium and San Diego's Jack Murphy Stadium is beautiful and exemplary of its time. With increased emphasis on "green" architecture, one would certainly hope this kind of effort would be viewed as the ultimate environmentally correct gesture.

 That is something, it’s a challenge I’d love to see cities and teams and neighborhoods take up because I think they could be magically redone. I don’t think teams are in the business of doing that, I think that at the end of the day, most baseball teams want to stick with their knitting, not be in the development business but be in the baseball business. And so, it takes, whoever owns it at the end of the day, usually a municipality, to have the foresight, the guts, and the risk to try something new. And I was really sorry that there was such a ground swell of interest in Memorial Stadium at the end, but it was too little too late. And it would be nice, even Comiskey, it’s ok trying to keep a piece of Comiskey just for the nostalgia of it. It failed because of cost. So it’d be nice to see Tiger Stadium given that chance.

BizBall: Just out of curiosity, how many upper bleacher seats are there in Fenway now, and how they can be sold out for rest of year if they are only supposedly only available day-of-game?

JMS: Well, I should probably direct you to someone who can give you a better answer than I, but I’ll give you a couple pieces of the answer.

The Red Sox did their best all year long to keep some tickets available for day-of-game sales, and that happened in part because we set some aside, and in part because we made an effort anytime tickets weren’t being used either by the military or corporate sponsors or house seats, or for whatever reason we might set them aside to begin with, and they got out in front of the fans. And because we had a huge advance sale it suited us fine to be able to put those out game day.

One of the reasons why the numbers don’t always add up if you’re sitting around with a pocket calculator is that we have a capacity of 36,298, but we are, we have only 35,000 positions, seated positions, so the rest are standing room. We often, like every other team in baseball are not permitted to count comp seats. So if the seat has not been sold, but there is a warm body in it, it doesn’t count for the posted attendance. So any military seats, and we have a several hundred of those, don’t count toward the total.

For instance, any house seats don’t count toward the total. So that’s the reason the capacity or occupancy numbers in most ballparks and the sellout numbers in most ballparks don’t match. Now this year the Red Sox seeing what a frenzy there was and seeing with some dismay what was happening on the scalping front, about ten days ago went ahead and released all of their tickets for the rest of the season. It meant that we were able to announce early that we had 81 sold out games, that we had sold out April all the way through October which is the first time that’s ever happened at Fenway and I think only two other teams have done that, Cleveland and Denver.

So it was also a wake up call to us that since we done we hope a fairly decent job of adding a few hundred seats a year in a way that doesn’t destroy Fenway, that the city may well give permission to increase the occupancy so that we can pick up more seats, although, as I said earlier, I think that John [Henry], Tom [Werner], and Larry [Lucchino] are all quite enamored with and committed, to continuing to continuing to be the smallest ballpark in the major leagues and aren’t looking to anything so radical as to destroy that.

BizBall: The new Comiskey Park opened only a year earlier than Camden Yards, yet their designs couldn’t have been more different. If Comiskey were to have become a big hit because Frank Thomas and the Sox had won a couple of World Series in the early 1990s and, if Camden Yards had been less successful because the Orioles played like the Devil Rays for their first couple of years there, would MLB teams would have built 10 clones of Comiskey by now instead of emulating Oriole Park?

JMS: I think that’s a great question. That’s a fascinating question.

I doubt it.

I think that the public is discerning enough to see the difference in the atmosphere and the setting, that that wouldn’t have happened. And while the Orioles had contending teams, they didn’t go nearly as far as they might have.

I love the question, but I don’t know the answer.

BizBall: What do see for the future for ballpark design, and what do you see are some trends that might break that the trend lately that tends to be more skewed toward brick and mortar? I hate to use the word, “radical” but do we see the possibility of designs that may involve more steel and glass?

JMS: Sure, I do happen to be a fan of the idea that a ballpark should fit with its surroundings, but that doesn’t mean it has to mimic its surroundings. And I don’t there’s anything about brick that suggests that it’s the only building material for baseball out there. It is a traditional one for those parks that are built in older urban settings, it’s often an appropriate material because so many buildings around them are also masonry.

 But, I don’t think that means that modern design isn’t a good thing by any stretch of the imagination. And, it would be terrific to see something done that was of modern vocabulary.

I don’t think that’s what makes or breaks a wonderful ballpark. I think it’s the spirit – the energy of the fans inside it that will make or break a ballpark’s ability to be perceived as something that has longevity.

 The following interview was originally published on the SABR Business of Baseball website, and can be read here: SABR Business of Baseball Interviews Page 

Interview conducted by Maury Brown on 9/22//04.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?