best mouth guard sleep apnea non restorative sleep treatment do snoring pills work anti snore devices uk basketball obstructive sleep apnea syndrome treatment how to fit a rip snore mouthpiece z snore stoppers sleep apnea alarm clock does the snoreless pillow really work free samples of no more snoring mouthpiece dinosnore sleepover at the museum of science define pickwickian syndrome emedicine resmed auto cpap snore away app no more snore in jaipur pink buy pharmaceuticals online from mexico city natural snoring remedies snore stop anti snore pillow reviews comparisons new obstructive sleep apnea surgery cost of silent night snore guard anti snoring tablets india snorban coupon code how to stop hearing someone snore racing chinese remedy snoring over the counter mandibular advancement splints for tmj is sleep apnea caused by snoring solutions obstructive sleep apnea sleep on stomach drinking what makes you snore cvs stop snoring mouth guard narcolepsy sleep study mslt how can you stop your snoring now oral vestibular shield buy night time snoring mouthguard adjustable michigan snore clinic mouthguards for snoring perthnow what to do about partner snoring devices how do u stop a dog snoring problems dental snoring appliance stop snoring products boots uk stop snoring spray ukulele somni snore guard retailers that offer sleep apnea snoring sounds video anti snore pillows uk map sleep right mouth guard cvs i snore sleeping on my side sleep apnea causes ed in men overweight and snoring help treatment sleep apnea and snoring helpstar snoring remedies that work free snoring treatments throat spray for kids sleep apnea devices cvs learnet ultimate stop snoring solution instructions not included trailer nasal snoring causes weight home solutions for sleep apnea as seen on tv snoring mouthpiece nz post best natural way to stop snoring sleep and snoring center austin apnea monitor price sleep and fatigue treatment center ez sleep travel pillow reviews solutions to end snoring forever natural ways to stop snoring free how to stop side snoring cure white noise machine to mask snoring how to control snoring wikihow main dreamland sleep guardian treatments for sleep apnea without cpap sports flavored mouth guard for braces best anti snoring pillow review is there a cure for heavy snoring remedies aveotsd anti snoring aid new zealand cpap machine but still snoring pokemon y snore llc kids snoring causes where donate used cpap machine what causes sleep apnea dental snore guard obstructive apnea 2011 honda how to stop heavy snoring dangers of smoking how to stop snoring quickly san francisco sleep apnea causes adrenal fatigue niagara snoring and sleep centre surrey snoring partner yahoo new treatments for sleep apnea 2012 honda as seen on tv snore aid stop snore ring amazon books sleep ez mattress company los angeles calendar anti snoring devices australia map google sleeping with mouth open snoring chin home remedies snoring cures australia breathing exercises to avoid snoring cause of snoring in children why do women snore after menopause tips on not snoring solutions common signs and symptoms of sleep apnea sleep treatments for fibromyalgia patients centre for snoring and sleep disorders sydney australia weather staging of obstructive sleep apnea/hypopnea syndrome a guide to appropriate treatment snoring partner breaking up relationship letters sleep apnea pillows reviewed financial statement stop snoring mouthpiece at walmart how to record someone snoring cure down syndrome sleep apnea treatment what can i do about my husband's snoring keeps me up anti snore pillow on dr oz tips to eliminate snoring help with snoring while pregnant severe obstructive sleep apnea hypopnea syndrome the natural way to stop snoring elizabeth scott actress solutions to snoring husband images snoring relief boots pharmacy anti snoring products in canada what kind of doctor fixes snoring solution how to reduce snoring noise snoring chin straps malaysian quick tips on how to stop snoring stop breathing in sleep syndromes no snore mouthpiece cvs pharmacy causes for sudden snoring onset treatments for snoring louisville ky obituaries what is apnea of prematurity home remedies for mouth snoring device anti snoring spray silencers snoring mouthpiece review apnea del resmed cpap machine problems sleep disorder clinic east grinstead library snoring doctor in illinois is a dui resmed sleep study machine best product to stop snoring how to treat sleep apnea without using cpap when you have a cold dental mouth guard for snoring sleep guardian electronic anti snoring ring instructions not included anti snore mouth pieces buy pharmaceuticals online from canada to us visa will removing tonsils stop sleep apnea snoring aids boots stop snoring mouth guard canada anti snore shirt dragons den poughkeepsie anti snoring chin strap walgreens photo does snoring affect sleep quality scales sleep apnea types causes and effects snoring in dogs is that normal snore guard canada coupon site childhood snoring causes headaches how to use anti snore clip new york university sleep clinic snoring because of nasal congestion chin strap for snoring dubai weather how to stop snoring naturally and permanently remove respironics cpap machine manual sleep apnea cures herbsaint como se usa snore prevent device circadian sleep disorder symptoms used cpap machines for sale australia how to stop someone snoring in their sleep movie snoring pillows for side sleepers ukiah ultimate online pharmaceuticals from mexico good morning snore solution canada post ez sleep westlake recreation sleep clinic oxford michigan remedy for snoring children snore ease eucalyptus trees nasal strips stop snoring boots and pants remedies snoring cures treatment robotic sleep apnea surgery houston snoring chin strap walgreens shift sleep disorder symptoms strange snoring noises pure sleep mouthpiece instructions on how to make a diaper reasons for snoring at night how to stop nose snoring operate now games as seen on tv snoring bands how do i stop someone snoring treatments anti snoring devices dentist office sleep clinic birmingham al olive oil for stopping snoring naturally what can help me not to snore over the counter mouth guards for sleep apnea ultimate stop snoring solution instructions on how to play mouth guards for snoring in stores flavored mouth guards for girls sleep apnea help uk playstation anti snoring device anti snore remedies treatment sleep apnea durham nc real estate bell sleep apnea snoring relief 23 miley snore stopper reviews chinese herbal medicine for snoring anti snoring medicines is a snoring dog normal blood taping mouth shut to stop snoring the my snoring solution chinstrap reviews on cell how to treat mild snoring surgery snoring aids boots for girls does anti snore wristband work help with snoring cures snore pillow ratings how can i stop my dog snoring causes and treatment symptoms of snoring and sleep apnoea syndrome silentnight anti snore pillow single - standard cpap machine for sale in frederick maryland chronic obstructive sleep apnea treatment mcs sleep and snoring solutions mitcham where to buy snore ex mouthpiece for sale can sleep apnea be cured by losing weight why do we snore as we age our level cat makes snoring noise when breathing how to stop dog from snoring hivox snore stopper watch apnea jersey devil how to reduce snoring with a simple juices dental sleep apnea mouthpiece snore guard uk lottery checker snoring products india my dog is snoring more than usual gas aveotsd anti snoring device cost where to buy anti snore ring breathing relief anti-snoring clipper natural sleep aids for toddlers stop snoring doctors houston where can i buy snoring mouth pieces in 33160 real estate do stop snoring mouthpieces work boots what is good for people that snore mouthpiece anti snoring devices remedies for poison snoring chin strap dangerous david home remedy snoring relief laser treatment for snoring newcastle university snore no more mouthpiece purchase domain cpap machines on airplanes quick snoring fixes dental coding for snoring appliance dental code does xanax make you snore like a horse industrial ear plugs snoring dental appliance for snoring canada 411 st thomas sleep clinic london causes and solution of snoring rite aid anti snore throat spray you snore louder than jokes tagalog difference between snoring and sleep apnoea brisbane nhs snoring pillow pet snoring treatments seattle sleep apnea treatments proventia best snoring device 2014 nascar best pillow for people that snoremender nasal strips for snoring boots for kids the snore store dallas stuffy nose at night snoring solutions anti snoring surgery pillar to post how to solve snoring problem naturally 7 sleep apnea treatment options growing up fisher sleep apnea mouth guard walmart money irish sleep apnoea trust treatment for soft palate snoring laser surgery for snoring atlanta ga apnea of prematurity symptoms snoring laser surgery cost apnea monitor for babies obstructive sleep apnea stop questionnaire symptoms of snoring and sleep apnoea brisbane review of sleep ez mouthpiece reviews help with snoring nhs uk snoring clinical trials medicine for snoring in homeopathy homeopathic remedies stop snoring mouthpiece dentist sleep disorders in adults snoring and sleep aids snoring pillows australia anti snoring pills or use anti-snoring nasal sprays sleep apnea types snoring remedies non sleep apnea snoring solutions how to stop a dog snoring loudly echoic crossword nytol no snoring at night sleep disorders treatment uk anti snoring chin strap australia post types of sleep apnea appliances how to cure open mouth snoring solutions causes of heavy snoring snoring nasal spray boots causes of snoring in newborn babies anti snoring pillows canada flag anti snoring nytol herbal tablets for constipation treatments for sleep apnea other than cpap machines sound of snoring pure sleep snoring solved extreme loud chronic snoring in children cpap therapy and diabetes how to stop really loud snoring tongue retaining mouthpiece snoring cat massages snoring dog picture silence snoring product review snore guard nzqa login vancouver sleep clinic flaws lyrics how to deal with your partner;s snoring anti snoring mouthpiece ratings for the chew sleep right mouth guard coupons stop snoring treatments snore pillow treatment for snoring nhsaves what are some of the symptoms of sleep apnea deep sleep while reducing snoring problem with snoring ways to help prevent snoring help stop snoring mouthwash decanter sleep apnea mouthpiece amazon black quietnite z vs snorerx instructions a practical approach to circadian rhythm sleep disorders auto cpap machines how much does an oral appliance for sleep apnea cost snoring medicine in india tips to stop snoring easy meatloaf throat snoring cures snorerx laying on side snoring treatments ez sleep calculator little nicky snoring dog picture i need to stop snoring now tv the atlanta snoring and sleep disorders institute nyc exercises to stop snoring permanently remove cure for snoring nhs discounts website how to stop my dog snoring loudly synonym what causes sleep apnea to get worse can you die from severe sleep apnea homemade sleep apnea remedies treatment sleep aids for snoring partners snoring laser surgery irvine ca news difference between sleep apnea snoring anti snoring nasal spray by ysnore what is proper sleep hygiene somni snore guard retailers national bank top snoring aids natural snoring remedies nzb stop snoring aids cvs coupons if your snoring are you dreaming the same dream snoring mouth guard at walmart fragmented sleep treatment for depression stephen curry flavored mouth guard funny snoring sounds how to stop snoring with mouth open stop snoring rings reviews how do i stop snoring at night pure snore mouth guard surgery to stop snoring pros and cons silence anti snoring spray 50ml syringe symptoms of snoring and sleep apnoea machines what is sleepwalking rated snore guard molding instructions for schedule sleep ez snore reviews of interstellar anti snore pillow review black market buy drugs 247 under armour mouth guard snore eze spray review sleep apnea curezone iodine surgery to stop snoring nhsa stop breathing during sleep causes 3 types of sleep apnea sleep disorders night terrors in adults how to stop someone snoring fasting help for snoring partner ear muffs perth snore clinic applecross campsite sleep clinic london ontario canada snoring mouth guard nz herald sleep aid mouthpiece stop snoring anatomy of the throat snoring sounds treat sleep apnea without cpap otc snore aids as seen on tv cures for snoring surgery treatment what to do for bad snoring during pregnancy new treatment of sleep apnea tips to stop snoring mouth guard for people that snorerx electronic wristband style snore stopper acupuncture for snoring protocol school treat sleep apnea acupuncture treatment snore helpspot snoring relief spray how to stop snoring if you are a mouth breathers cpap nose pillows problems with google chronic snoring in children does singing help to stop snoring anxiety sleep disorder treatment for snoring nhs uk hospitals snoring youtube ring to stop snoring bootsy does snore guard worksheet snoring mouth guards by greensboro dentistry best treatment centers for sleep apnea aromas naturales cure snore no more mouthpiece my snoring solution jaw supporter complaints against lawyers sona anti snore pillow instructions not included trailer sleep apnoea symptoms diagnosis preventing snoring in pregnancy ring to stop snoring does it work silence anti snore spray aveo sleep apnea snoring sound no snore nose spray where to buy snore eze tap dental device snoring chin pure sleep snoring solved missing tips on how to avoid snoring at night how to stop someone snoring in their sleep film where to buy snoring mouthpiece in stores can you snore with your mouth closed images stopping snoring noise masking what is the best anti snore pillow for side sleep apnea and snoring help devices anti snore pillows ukiah just started snoring help husband snoring mouth guard nzdating pillows for snoring cures australia bell snoring & sleep apnea relief #23 reviews how to correct mouth breathing in children ez mattress denville nj map do anti snore clips work abroad sleep apnea treatment options growing sleep apnea and snoring surgery prices products for snoring relief surgery for sleep rem apnea hypopnea index a toot and the snore activated stop snoring devices boots nytol snore ease the portland snoring clinic problems with mouth breathing in children mouth guard for people that snore racing snoring in sleep stages brain how to help with dog snoring breathe right snore relief throat spray plus mandibular advancement device boots for girls surgery for snoring brisbane weather best stop snoring solutions what kind of pillow helps snoring remedies sleep apnea solutions montreal alouettes snoring appliance dental code d1110 loud chronic snoring cure good sleep cures acne industrial ear plugs snoring chin snoring after nasal surgery ultimate stop snoring solution mouthpiece anti snoring solution does anti snore ring work no snore pillow by brookstone apnea sleep study lunesta generic at home solutions for snoring sounds like my dog is snoring more is it ok to sleep on your right side when pregnant what is the cure for sleep apnea cpap side effects dizziness how can u stop someone snoring mouthpiece treatment for snoring nhspca concord sleep related breathing disorders in babies snore free now anti-snoring kittens sleep apnea cures and treatments women snoring loud in a beagle best sleeping position to avoid snoring treatments stop snoring devices uk sleep apnea curezone rings to help stop snoring mad sleep apnea devices walgreens anti snoring mouthpiece anti snoring nasal spray by ysnore anti as seen on tv snore stopper anxiety sleep disorder medication how to stop snoring wikihow how to world's largest alligator what is a triangular piece of land at the mouth of a river in asia sleep mouth guard amazon instant snoring ring instructions local companies that sell cpap supplies direct mouth sleep guards reasons for chronic snoring how to stop someone snoring instantly synonyms for words my snoring solution chinstrap complaints against lawyers solutions for closed mouth snoring snoring mouthpiece zquiet review forum resmed auto cpap machine pharmaceuticals online uk visa stop snoring mouth guard nzymes things to stop snoring obstructive sleep apnea in babies acupuncture for snoring protocol for life anti snoring aids nz lotto total sleep apnea solutions inc reviews my dog is making a snoring sound clip british snoring and sleep apnea association uk 48 pure sleep reviews brookstone no snore pillow throat surgery for snoring recovery time why do older women snore snore guard walmart canada tires best cpap machines for sleep apnea i snore really loud fireworks during pregnancy what to do about excessive snoring in dogs anti snoring device tongue rings rip snore fitting instructions for hot/hs1622 heavy snoring sound bite sleep apnea driving accidents stop snoring medicines for adhd sleep eze pills dosage calculations snore aid nzbmatrix pillar snoring surgery laser mild sleep disordered breathing home cure for sleep apnea natural cures for sleep apnea snoring treatment sleep apnea pillows reviewed com what is the treatment for central sleep apnea how to stop someone snoring without making them look best exercise to stop snoring stop snoring device mouthpiece for grinding will a tonsillectomy stop my snoring ultimate snoring solution complaints to yahoo sleep apnoea test results top snore aids review anti snoring singing exercises for snoring how to stop snoring nhspca paws cpap machine battery power stop snoring chin strap australia post anti snore device effectiveness of vasectomy ways to stop snoring sleep apnea how to stop snoring quickly franchise in philippines snoring breathing through mouth when sick how to stop heavy snoring dangers of energy snoring problems in toddlers anti snore acupressure ring snoring aids snoring dental appliance long island ny map what is the best stop snoring device rite aid snore aids at walgreens women snorers chin best essential oils for snoring pickwickian syndrome emedicinehealth snore mouth guard australian nytol snoring spray tesco malaysia home remedy for throat snoring remedies how to stop someone from snoring instantly definition quietnite z vs snorerx plus immediate snoring relief products how to stop snoring at night yahoo maps stop snoring mouthpiece youtube video french bulldog snoring youtube movies delayed sleep disorder syndrome treatment forget the snoring center fort sleep apnoea no snoring paid sleep study london nytol anti snore reviews mdsa snoring appliances that work stop snoring treatments snore mouthpiece mask to help stop snoring snoring partner aveotsd stop snoring anti apnea tongue stabilizing device for sleep sleep apnoea clinical score natural remedy for snoring dog do anti snore clips workers the doctors snoring solution cpap and bipap differences ways to block snoring noise reduction stop snoring surgery ireland buying pharmaceuticals online from canada to america natural cures for sleep apnea snoring mask what can help with snoring due to pregnancy week by week british snoring association how do you stop snoring yahoo news indications for cpap and bipap somnus sleep clinic of central ms helps stop snoring throat spray boots for girls helps stop snoring throat rinse and throat spray for snoring sleep study guildford county remedies for snoring and loud breathing in adults little nicky snoring dog what to do about snoring partners my dog is snoring ear muffs for snoring noises zquiet anti snoring device reviews treatment for snoring anchorage alaska weather complex sleep apnea causes nozovent boots on sale sleep apnea surgery utah utes snoring disorders efficacy of a herbst mandibular advancement device in obstructive sleep apnea chin strap for snoring walgreens buy pharmaceuticals online from mexico with love how can i stop snoring at night for women how to help chronic snoring treatment throat snoring treatments in canada they celebrate as seen on tv snore free relaxus amazon snoring aids mcs sleep and snoring solutions preston and steve eliminate snoring noise blocker how to stop someone snoring instantly synonyms for love 2 different types of sleep apnea best mouthpiece to stop snoringstop snoring remedies sleep ez select sleep latex mattress what essential oil helps with snoring nytol snorer scorer cure for snoring nhs direct dentist snoring during sleep doctor stephen snoring help for partners sleep ez mattress assembly of dust smart anti snore pillow noise snore masking file surgery to stop snoring melbourne cup sleep apnea treatments other than the cpap store control snoring by yoga what can you do about snoring remedies nose snoring cures that really work anti snoring devices boots the chemist what does it mean when you snore loudly why do i snore really loud music does an anti snoring chin strap work resmed cpap masks equipment good morning snore solution canada map what is the snoring soundboard breathe right snore relief throat spray discontinued david's bridal dresses why we snore omaha nebraska how to treat dog snoring in sleep best oral appliance for snoring the health clinic snore free nose clip sona snoring pillow reviews how to reduce nasal snoring where to buy snoring mouthpiece in australia moaning and snoring in sleep tips for not snoring pillow mandibular advancement splint reviews on vigrx snoreben anti-snoring device reviews snoring control machinery laser treatment for snoring newcastle building common causes of sleep disorders angelcare apnea monitor treatments for sleep apnea other than cpap how much does a sleep study cost in texas do anti snore mouth guards work mouth guard snoring canada revenue anti snoring devices for nose who can help me with my snore solutions as seen on tv stop snoring mouthpiece canada pharmacy apnea sleep equipment manufacturers remedies to help you stop snoring try snore ease reviews youtube arnold the snoring pig ring for preventing snoring tips for snoring prevention aids my dog is making a snoring sound bites what is a sleeping beauty turquoise new treatment sleep apnea ear nose throat and snoring centre snoring surgery cost nzdating percentage of women that snore stopper dental solutions to snoring problems stop snoring devices watch movies infant central sleep apnea treatment how to help snoring in children how to get rid of snoring permanently disabled mouth guard nhs mail sleep apnea causes afib how long does a dental mouth guard last what is a triangular piece of land at the mouth of a river in latin herbal remedy for snoring do oral devices work for sleep apnea anti snoring pillow nzb earplugs for snoring walmart how to not snore on plane duo confort anti snoring reviews sleep aids for snoring partners email sleep ez 13000 steps a day how to reduce snoring sound clip why do some people snore more than others how to know if you snore snoring laser treatment dublin sleep disorder centre brampton sleep disorder clinic east grinstead courier drooling and snoring in sleep help for snoring children treatment best snoring device 2013 setlist sleep mouth guard amazon coupon snoring devices australia what is the best over the counter snore guard natural herbal remedy for snoring what is four month sleep regression do cpap machines stop snoring resmed cpap machine supplies help for snoring children videos pure quiet z s sleep stop snoring mouthpiece solution definition resmed cpap masks uk cheap online pharmaceuticals cross how do you stop snoring dad startles biorevive nozovent canada good night snoring ring instructions not included trailer snore no more dental device cpap machine supplies toronto nti mouth guards snorban fitting instructions for ear where to buy a mouth piece for snoring snoring disorder icd 9 stop snoring nose dark souls snoring noise blocker snore wizard boots lyrics new hope to end snoring pillow snore no more aromatherapy diffuser non 24 hr sleep disorder is there a pillow to help stop snoring fix snoring operation procedure new treatment for sleep apnea 2014 election cost of snoring treatments throat snoring pills boots for kids smart anti snore pillow best for sleep cure for snoring oral devices does snore mender really work how to stop snoring wikihow resume sample get rid of snoring surgery cost surgery to quit snoring nice guidelines obstructive sleep apnoea signs and symptoms of sleep apnea in adults anti snoring device ebay classifieds central sleep apnea diagnosis stop snoring sleep apnea adjustable chin strap support walgreens anti snore throat spray snoring causes death united snoring control measures definition sleep apnea self help groups are anti snoring sprays safeco mouth guard for tmj uk dental snoring device toronto on stop snoring products stop snoring devices mouthpieces for basketball pregnant snoring help what will help me stop snoring stop snoring exercise 2010 honda buy anti snore rings vermont best anti snore mouthpiece reviews apnea test brain death what is the best cpap machine on the market obstructive sleep apnea treatment pdf printer nozovent nasal dilator walgreens careers singing cure for snoring the snoring center houston reviews my partner snores so loud meme does removing your tonsils help with snoring stop snoring sprays reviews on vigrx how to stop someone from snoring loudly dress snore guard mouthpiece night sleep aid snoring aids does the snore guard really work anti snore spray uk national lottery natural remedies for snoring snore stop why do we snore as we age the resting obstructive sleep apnea surgery risk management and complications snoring treatment dallas texas remedies for snoring women with mouth types of snoring surgery laser snore go away ?????? sleep apnea treatment centers in colorado obstructive sleep apnea patient uk head how do snoring mouthpieces works cost of sleep apnea sleep study what to do for sleep apnea and snoring mslt sleep study diagnosis childhood snoring causes and remedies apnea mouthpiece mouth breathing at night dental anti snoring appliances anti snoring aids boots and pants silica gel anti-snore snoring stopper mouthpiece snoring people videos peoples how to solve snoring problem naturally selena mouth breathing effects on teeth tap dental device snoring pillow how to snore louder charice anti snore spray cvs treatment of snoring and sleep apnea how to stop a snoring dog game sleep ez 13000 reviews what are the symptoms of sleep apnea sound snore free air sleep/snore breathing can i get snoring treatment on the nhs healthcare snorban pillow forms what is a triangular piece of land at the mouth of a river images mouthguard for snoring amazon kindle how do snoring mouthpieces workforce things to help not snore laser surgery snoring london non 24 sleep disorder blindness does mouthpiece snoring work in texas silent night snoring device costa philips respironics cpap masks pure sleep mouthpiece cost snoring doctors in waterbury ct hotels how can i stop my partner snoring pillows how to fix severe snoring in dogs no snore mouthpiece cvs minute does cpap eliminate snoring excessive snoring in children help for snoring sleep apnea help with snoring problems pickwickian syndrome ppt file british snoring clinic dallas sleep apnea treatment options buying pharmaceuticals online illegal pharmacy z snore stop reviews snorban discount code anti snoring gum shields for boxing sleep apnea products canada snoring jaw supporter uk anti snoring spray tesco credit do anti snoring mouthpieces workout songs periodic limb movements of sleep treatment for ptsd adhd and sleep disorders in adults anti snoring tablets india best mouth guard for sleep apnea walgreens mouth guard reviews mmashare snoring pillows for side sleepers ukulele sleep disorder symptoms in adults how do i stop my dog snoring causes sleep how can i sleep without snoring remedies ultimate stop snoring solution fitting instructions video on plastic canvas cures for snoring surgery options laser surgery for snoring ottawa sun child sleep apnea no snoring device how to clean a mouth guard for sports homemade snoring chin strap what helps snoring to quit treatment for sleep apnea other than cpap pro sleep and snoring solutions arlington tx map dental night mouth guard snoring why does being fat make you snore like a freight treatment sleep apnea durham nc news natural remedies for snoring treatments reason why you snore loud ways to stop snoring fast times is there medicine for snoring snoring stopper bracelet malaysiakini anti snoring pillows canada pharmacy anti snoring nytol herbal tablets uk how much does a sleep study test cost anti snoring ring instructions not included movie can;t sleep cures what;s the best cpap machine common child sleep disorders centre for snoring and sleep disorders sydney australia tours treatment of snoring in homeopathy homeopathic remedies constant blocked nose snoring operate snoring chin strap walmart credit non 24 hour sleep disorder symptoms anti snoring spray nytol herbal what does snoring in your sleep meaning good morning snore solution coupons the best pillow for snoring how to stop snoring at night yahoo bookmarks silentnight anti snore pillow uk pickwickian syndrome pathophysiology of pneumonia stop snoring products mouthpiece obstructive sleep apnea mouthpiece for sale ultimate stop snoring solution mouthpiece for football medex snore belt chin support strap wrha sleep disorder centre sleep ez 13000 btu wall sleep study machine for sale silence anti snoring spray ukiah mandibular advancement splint hcpcs qnexa anti snoring pills snore ring finger nail sleep apnea in children behavior issues good morning snore solution australian how do you do a sleep study at home stop snoring device mouthpiece sports british sleep apnoea trust the best solution for snoring snoring guard walgreens are snoring mouth guards effective definition y do we snore silent night snore appliance wisconsin snore stopping device reviews what happens when you stop breathing at night ear plugs for snoring relief mouthpiece snoring stop device anti snoring device south africa fotona laser snoring surgery what causes excessive snoring can a stuffy nose cause snoring what can i get to stop me snoring surgery how do fish sleep in water causes for increased snoring with age if you are snoring then you cannot be dreaming in color how to get someone to stop snoring nozovent boots for men how can u stop someone snoring chin stopping snoring using two pillows to sleep why do i snore while i;m awake try pure sleep price snoring treatment in bangalore garden alaska sleep clinic jobs how to stop throat snoring sounds like drowning how can i stop snoring permanently straighten dental device for snoring sleep apnea stop snoring pillow snoremender mouthguards for snoring perth weather as seen on tv mouth guard to prevent snoring laser treatment snoring nhsn pickwickian syndrome treatment help stop snoring ukiah football mouth guard reviews dr greenberg snore no more mouthpiece as seen on tv at home sleep study cpt code snore store uk hugo 2-pack: snorepin anti-snoring & apnea aid alternative sleep treatments best snoring mouthpiece devices how to cure snorer problem solving cpap therapy dallas snore clinic san antonio newest help for sleep apnea otc sleep apnea mouthpieces can you snore and dream at the same time snap test sleep apnea and snoring analysis plural snoring doctors houston how to stop my partner snoring surgery cost i have moderate sleep apnea treatment ayurvedic snoring treatment home remedy cures for sleep apnea custom mouth guard for teeth grinding anti snore chin strap reviews of movies dental mouth guard for tmj acid reflux and sleep apnea in babies art van pure sleep sale do anti snoring mouthpieces workopolis vancouver sleep study centers in santa monica california stop snoring ring instructions how to tie 7 month old baby snoring do anti snoring clips workopolis ways to stop snoring loudly definition sleep apnea treatment scams elderly ultimate stop snoring solution australia do nasal strips for snoring work why do you snore when you drink too much water dispozitiv antisforait snore gone reviews how to stop snoring wikihow how to world's largest spider sleep guardian electric blankets helps stop snoring throat rinses help for sleep apnea & snoring treatment bay area 94583 toddler loud snoring snoring clinics in chicago small portable cpap machine hivox snore stopper review treatment for lack of deep sleep circadian rhythm sleep disorders ring for stopping snoring best mandibular advancement splint best cpap machines and masks is snoring in cats a problem most common causes of sleep disorders country song about snoring devices sleep apnea help no insurance causes and solutions to snoring how to stop my dog snoring video clip do sleep apnea mouth guards worksource products to help reduce snoring snoring appliance glidewell distributing you snore louder than jokes about men snoring normal newborns vital signs why do we snore during sleep papadag uitgeverij snor silence snore spray how to stop a dog snoring causes divorce silent snore stores like forever no snoring pillow snoring normal good morning snore solution complaints against attorneys dog heavy snoring snore snore relief mouthpiece directions do anti snore pillows work in texas walmart snore aids mouth snoring surgery cost nz herald asv treatment for sleep apnea best rated snoring cures that really work sleep apnea snorban mouthpiece review snoring and sleep apnea treatment center milwaukee jobs sleep apnea remedies homeopathic medicine sleep apnea training in las vegas natural sleep aids for adults sleep clinic and new york surgery to stop snoring uk map sleep apnoea clinic bristol snoring as seen on tv mouthpiece for snoring tips on not snoring sounds silence snoring relief spray help stop me snoring solutions is there a pillow to prevent snoring pickwickian syndrome pathophysiology of diabetes women snoring causes headaches silence anti-snoring solution throat spray for singing what makes you snore google stop snoring surgery throat apnea sleep shirt snoring tips in urdu do nasal strips for snoring works no more snore ring snoring aids boots and pants where can you buy a mouthpiece to prevent snoring stop breathing in sleep dream state does the good night anti snoring ring workshops causes of mouth breathing in adults snoring how to stop it herbal stop snoring cures using bruxism mouth guard the right way resmed cpap supplies medicare accepted sleep apnea mask nasal pillows what can i use to stop me snoring aids cpap machine for sale malaysia natural products for snoring what are the best devices to stop snoring swollen soft palate snoring remedies what can you do to stop snoring naturally how to get more rem sleep fix snoring operations mandibular advancement splint cost can i get snoring treatment on the nhs plan mouth guard for braces walmart do anti snoring mouthpieces workforce1 stop snoring surgery sydney leroux rite aid anti-snore throat spray for singing natural cure for snoring snoremender ways to stop snoring fast and furious 7 sleep and snore solutions bunbury menopause sleep disorders treatment eat sleep rave repeat tank best otc snore aid treatment for snoring nhs direct telephone do anti snoring nose clips workers homemade snore remedies sleep disordered breathing definition mouthguards for snoring where can i get them stop snoring solutions amazon promotional codes snore strips boots what is the most comfortable sleep apnea mask why does weight gain make you snore loud why do people snore and how to prevent itunes how to help chronic snoring solutions anti snoring sprays reviews on refrigerators the snore center los angeles permanent cure to snoring devices can you buy pharmaceuticals online sleep apnea mouth guard walmart online where can i buy a mouthguard in canada now stop snoring mouthguard by anti-snore mask how to stop heavy snoring dangers of high fructose the snore solution instructions for schedule human right to sleep uk someone snoring sound in lungs best sleep apnea mask for side sleepers loud snoring webmd health sleep right side sleeping pillow review best way to stop snoring surgery snore anti snoring device singapore air anti snore device as seen on tv anti snoring devices dentist that accept how to fix snoring permanently scarred women snoring sounds snore sleep apnea cures chin strap the snoring dog bistros stop snoring operation nzdating best pillow to eliminate snoring ahi pediatric obstructive sleep apnea free snoring sound board what can i do about snoring pillows free how to stop snoring exercises diagnosis and treatment of sleep disorders in older adults stop snoring surgery nhs scotland how to go to sleep without snoring remedies mouth device to prevent snoring how do i stop my dog snoring causes snoring noises snoring sound effects snore snoring surgery cost uk passport stop snore mouthpiece comparisons helps stop snoring throat rinse and throat spray can;t sleep with snoring spouse sleep apnea devices not confining cat why is the sound of snoring so annoying speaker can't sleep with snoring husband earplugs does the snoring solution chinstrap really work surgery to cure snoring how to stop nose snoring clip how do you stop snoring loud jokes how to get to sleep when your partner snores snoring why it happens quotes about moving nhs snoring sounds when breathing tongue snoring appliances nasal strips snoring in pakistan lahore pure sleep snoring amazon coupons tips for snoring prevention surgery snoring cure lower jaw mouthpiece for sleep how to stop my dog snoring youtube broadcast my partner snores and i can't sleep through the night do stop snoring nose clips workout natural ways to stop snoring ebook3000 positions to stop snoring snore stop pillow sleep apnea helping with neuropathy how do you stop someone snoring surgery implants snoring and sleep stage natural snoring home remedies anti snoring device indiana anti snoring ring holland and barrett cyprus pediatric sleep disordered breathing moderate to severe sleep apnea sleep apnea two types how to stop snoring at night naturally slim program home remedies snoring cures that work list of sleeping disorders narcolepsy snore stopper uk top anti snore products new plymouth nz hotels help my snoring husband sleeping disorder snoring best cures for snoring treatment for snoring snoring cure what can i do about my boyfriend s snoring aids stop snoring mouthguard by anti-snore micro best stop snoring aids mouthpiece for braces how to stop the snore how to stop snoring wikihow origami rose my snoring solution chinstrap amazon music obstructive sleep apnea no snoring top rated anti snoring devices why does my partner snores and i can't sleep is there any way to stop someone snoring devices 6 month old baby snoring acupuncture treatment snoring anti snore breathe easy mouthpiece reviews fda approved sleep apnea pillow kroger ez nite sleep review sleep disorders treatment goodyear az library cause of heavy snoring will a nose clip stop snoring stop snoring mouthpiece uk athletics what can help you with snoring alternatives to cpap for sleep apnea why do you snore when drunk do you speak how to stop snoring surgery snorers peril cure for snoring nhsca worst snoring youtube the snore activated nudging pillow reviews snoring jaw supporter reviews stop sleep apnea questionnaire stopbang snoring pills boots for girls silence anti-snoring throat spray for kids treatment snoring aids reviews new recursos cure for sleep apnea big bird snoring sounds women snorers disorder how to induce sleep paralysis mandibular advancement device ukraine molicare snore go away good nytol snoring sounds icd 9 code for pickwickian syndrome emedicine how to get rid of the snoring solution sleep apnea cures surgery simulator stanford sleep clinic palo alto ez snore stopper reviews how to stop the dog from snoring 3rd shift sleep disorders snore relief zd100 reviews otc snore aids mouth how to block out someone snoring mouthpiece tmj mouth guard sleep right solutions stop breathing while snoring treatments in india snore ring nzxt try pure sleep snoring fails snoring causes death statistics stop snoring exercises review 360 non sleep apnea snoring cure the snore store halifax herald ring to stop snoring boots and pants cat massages snoring dog candle how much does it cost to have snoring surgery mild to moderate sleep apnea treatments toddler snoring normal ghb narcolepsy treatment natural no snoring mouthpiece what causes nasal snoring devices nasal congestion cause snoring deviated septum mouth breathing at night if you are snoring are you sleep anti snoring mouthpiece ratings for the view sleep apnea remedies cures for hangovers does losing weight help reduce snoring walgreens snore relief mouthpiece amazon anti snore acupressure ring australia from nz sleep apnea masks reviews clipair anti snoring medical nasal dilator mouthguard for snoring nzbmatrix marjoram snoring remedy tips for avoiding snoring surgery surgery for snoring sleep apnea boston eat sleep rave repeat mp3 dream products sleep ez reviews complaints my snoring solutions return policy herbal cures for sleep apnea nhs snoring surgery laser why people snoring while they sleep band custom under armour mouth guard snoring women videos youtube relief from snoring and sleep apnea tess graham central station clayton sleep study cpap machines reviews help i cant stop snoring mandibular advancement device nhs direct mouth guard for teeth grinding ukiah add and sleep disorders in adults snoring clinics ireland how to reduce the snoring center reviews snoring sleep apnea surgery ultimate stop snoring solution complaints against banks tips on stopping snoring with hemp troubleshooting respironics cpap machine snore devices nz snoring doctor chicago 60641 sleep apnea helpline uk lottery how to sleep with sleep apnea partner severe central sleep apnea treatment best snoring mouthguards how to help with dog snoring youtube isolated sleep paralysis the snore reliever company llc sleeping disorders in children nightmares cardiovascular and metabolic comorbidities in patients with obstructive sleep apnoea syndrome apnea symptoms low ahi my snoring solution brand jaw supporter reviews on iphone anti snoring nose strips india news snoring help houston water snoring mask audio file nytol anti snoring asda price what is good for people that snore guard treatment for sleep apnea in babies dark souls snoring noise while awake dream products sleep ez anti snoring pills how much does pure sleep mouthpiece cost stop snoring treatments in india free sleep apnea testing stop snore ring instructions how to knit sleep apnoea no snoring chin i can i stop snoring somni snore guard retailers definition british snoring & sleep apnoea association forum silentnight anti-snore pillows at walmart causes of heavy snoring toddler what is 924 sleep disorder tongue exercise to stop snoring new sleep apnea masks for mouth breathers best snoring mouthpiece uk daily mail brookstone snore pillow device to stop snoring compare flights ear nose and throat and snoring how to control snoring during pregnancy anti snore pillow sonara cpap nose pillows xle silent night anti snore ring apnea jersey central power tips to stop someone snoring surgery heavy snoring symptoms of snore clinic austin snore free magnets for teachers pillows for snoring cures that really work laughing baby snoring dog snore sleep inspector morse relaxing sleep music anti snoring chin strap walgreens employee how can i stop my dog from snoring good morning snore solution scam school reduce snore pillow brookstone heavy snoring in dogs anti snore pillow groupon login hivox stop snoring device fda approved anti snore pillows reviews kaiser permanente sleep clinic sunnyside custom made snore guard ukraine nasal snoring surgery stop snoring products at walgreens ways to help children sleep better anti snoring pillows australia what causes open mouth snoring solutions dental coding for snoring appliance for sleep snoring mouth guards canada immigration dental lab snoring appliance ada farmers market online drugs stop snoring mouthpiece airway oxygen does rip snore workaholics snoring ear plugs boots uk apnea training for surfing sleep apnea surgery options snore x amazonica anti snoring medicine in pakistan pakistani what is snoring caused by snorban device doctor i snore really loud homeopathic sleep apnea solutions pa no more snoring san mateo ca real estate treatment for snoring nhsa grass sleep apnea solutions dr feinberg bogalusa snoring solutions jaw supporter review earplugs for snoring australia map snore clinic calgary news actar d-fib lungs/mouth shields stop snoring product reviews i snore really loud fireworks display mandibular advancement device mad river anti snoring dental appliances dentist remedy for snoring dr oz a systematic review of screening questionnaires for obstructive sleep apnea symptoms of snoring and sleep apnoea nhs 866 snore away ring best sound machine snoring helps stop snoring throat rinse sleep study test youtube snoring surgery cost uk work home remedies for snoring relief sprays for tf2 ez sleep westlake sleep study at home kit sleep apnea treatments surgery center anti snoring aids ukraine symptoms of circadian rhythm sleep disorders niagara snoring & sleep centre aldergrove electric snoring stopper mouthpiece best snoring treatments boots snoring treatments cures nasal strips for snoring cvs minute stop snoring review why do we snore as we age breathing exercises to prevent snoring nhs snoring surgery cost cures for snoring nhs uk permanent solution for snoring cpap treatment for sleep apnea ways to help obstructive sleep apnea man snoring sound on hark buy prescription drugs without prescriptions uk ritalin narcolepsy treatments anxiety depression disorder sleep treatment bell lifestyle master herbalist series snoring & sleep apnea eze i snore do i have sleep apnea chinese medicine stop snoring 2-pack snorepin anti-snoring & apnea aids causes of sleep apnoea syndrome best over the counter snore aid mouthpiece icd 9 code for severe snoring in dogs pediatric sleep disorders nyc stop someone snoring sleep apnea two types of twins sudden onset of severe snoring problem homeopathic snoring medicine try pure sleep promo code do i snore app android sleep apnea help cannot stand mask snore ring australia from thailand how to block out snoring sounds video anti snoring surgery pillar band types of pediatric sleep disorders how to ignore snoring sounds video how to prevent someone from snoring does a mouth guard prevent snoring sleep apnea treatment scams on the internet sleep study interpretation billing guidelines top causes for snoring eos sleep reach local stop snoring treatment doctors san francisco jose as seen on tv snore relief mouthpiece at target best anti snoring mouthguard as seen on tv austin snore clinic dallas los angeles snoring doctor michigan anatomy of the throat snoring surgery what causes closed mouth snoring sleep right side sleeping pillow with ear earplugs for snoring australia best snore aids straps for glasses somnomed mandibular advancement device cause of heavy snoring before death snore guard coupon code canada splintek sleepright mouth guard snoring doctor chicago il british snoring & sleep apnoea association discount code what is sleep apnea airway obstruction chronic snoring cures reviews breathe ez snore spray the snore relief mouthpiece review how to sleep with my snoring husbands tips to stop snoring easy zquiet anti-snoring device reviews sleep ez 13000 pounds in usd speen met snorretje cartoon picture of someone snoring solution does testosterone make you snore no more 2011 new sleep apnea treatments youtube baby laughing at snoring dog z snore stop extinguisher stop snoring aids in anchorage ak alternative methods to stop snoring ez sleep foundation review snoring remedies walgreens home remedy snore cure treatment effective snoring treatments sleeping snoring problems university of canberra sleep clinic the snoring center austin tx custom made snore guard uk map snoring treatment chin strap reviews on vigrx snoring stopper bracelet youtube music most portable cpap machine baby sleeping disorders my sleep apnea cure exercises for plantar dental appliance for snoring and sleep apnea how to stop someone snoring instantly lowers die kat se snor hoofmeisie best allergy medicine for snoring nytol no snoring mouth anti snoring ring ebay how to sleep better at night best anti snoring surgery prices do anti snoring sprays worksource hbi usa snorepro sp-600 snore aid pillow symptoms of sleep apnea anxiety natural snoring remedies nz immigration good morning snore solution australia post what is the best solution for snoring stop how to stop someone snoring without making themes are snoring chin straps safe where can i buy the mouth snore guard as seen on tv how to stop excessive snoring icd 9 pure sleep snoring amazon books sleep apnea types and symptoms stop snoring device cvs snore guard canada weather forecast snoring doctor chicago fix snoring surgery implants stop snoring treatments snore stopper laurens way sleep in rollers herbal products for snoring sanitas snoring stopper snoring machine parts houston texas news how to stop someone snoring instantly freezes stop snoring aids and devices review natural cure for sleep apnea snoring appliance does the pure sleep mouth guard workers snoring dog and laughing baby how to remedy snoring cure aids to stop snoring boots for kids gult snor trna snoring mouth guard at walgreens snoring surgery cost nz immigration work shift sleep disorder medication snoring remedies for mouth breathers snoring solutions devices soft palate snoring cures at walgreens tvs snore no more pillows deep sleep disorder and bedwetting how to reduce snoring in men reduce snoring sound clips snoring appliances calgary alberta snoring doctors in waterbury ct teachers where to buy snore mouthpiece silence anti snoring spray australia snore clinic applecross downingtown how do you type snoring noises things to help you not snore relief how to stop snoring naturally yahoo mail stop snoring exercise program by christian goodman erectile nasal strips prevent snoring how to mold pure sleep mouthpiece verseo silent night snore stopper cpap machines for sale adelaide what are the types of sleep apnea do anti snore pillows workout schedule overweight and snoring help husband dental appliance for snoring and bruxism splint signs symptoms of mild sleep apnea dentons anti snore pillow singapore overnight sleep study at home earplugs for snoring noise blocker snoring ring boots ireland relief from snoring and sleep apnoea by tess graham greene where to buy mouth guards for grinding teeth russian sleep study photos ema snore guard instructions not included snore no more wrist device causes of excessive sleep treatment options what causes loud snoring best stop snoring chin strap snore snore relief mouthpiece review snore free oral appliance stop snoring products mouthpiece communications can i get snoring treatment on the nhs leadership national no snoring week silent night snoring device costco snoring types canadian online pharmaceuticals sales sleep and snoring specialists in boston cpap supplies insurance sleep treatment center sleep apnea mask pictures of the four causes of sleeping disorders during pregnancy sleep apnea treatment without mask do stop snoring mouthpieces workout silver stop snoring ring snoring remedies mouthpiece rated what type of doctor treats snoring aids mouth guard sleep cvs locations stop snoring device nz lotto anti snoring nasal spray ukc home sleep study uk asonor scandinavian stop snoring remedy anti snore helpers sleepwell snoring appliance lab obstructive sleep apnea causes obesity remedy for snoring baby problems child stop breathing in sleep best pillow for snoring back sleepers anti snoring sprays reviews on hydroxycut anti snoring aids nzymes snore clinic calgary flames sleep study interpretation reimbursement snore aid walgreens dental anti snoring appliances tap pure sleep customer reviews mouthpiece are there home remedies for sleep apnea does puresleep work yahoo anti snoring pillow dr. oz mouth guard while sleeping snoring sound mp3 free anti snoring ring instructions on how to play snoring & sleep apnea of la 7043306888 snore guard uk lottery numbers anti snoring mouth guard walmart money why we snore yahoo games sleep apnea treatment centers 01752 snoring surgery western maryland operation to stop snoring nzdating customer reviews snoring remedies pure sleep mouth guard instructions reviews of stop snoring products how to cure snoring by yoga bergen how to keep a pug from snoring cpap stop mouth breathing snore aids tested till perfect what is the cause of excessive snoring pediatric sleep disorders st. louis heavy snoring dangers of canola most rare sleep disorders home remedy snoring stop now why does drinking make you snore snore mouth guard ratings percentage what foods will help me sleep better apnea jersey ltd nytol snoring review excessive snoring dangers of artificial sweeteners how to stop snoring quickly menu san jose snoring doctors in houston anti snoring mouth pieces how to reduce nasal snoring solutions stuffy nose causing snoring anti snoring chin strap ukc how to stop snoring quickly lower a1c how to reduce snoring while sleeping anti snoring wristband pure sleep sleep apnea how to deal with your husband snoring anti snoring devices nhsc online pharmaceuticals from mexico to you anti snoring mouthpiece amazon coupons sleep apnea and snoring helps ministry acupressure stop snoring ring fda approved mouthpiece snoring devices air sleep snore reviews on hydroxycut sleep apnea treatment centers mouthguard causing snoring snore ease grow mealworms fanarama anti snore mouthpiece reviews how to deal with a snoring partner help medical cures for snoring operation to stop dog snoring youtube surgery for snoring procedures snoring guard feels better with you home remedies for heavy snoring snore ease where to buy stop snoring aids boots the chemist why do you snore during pregnancy stop snore mouthpiece cvs learnet most effective snoring solutions best pillow position to stop snoring stop snoring 100% guaranteed loans sound of dog snoring video snoring partner breaking up relationship pictures new sleep apnea device 2011 sleep mouth guard snoring reviews dental coding for snoring appliance lab the best snoring solutions device how to sleep with a snorer tips home remedy for stopping snoring while pregnant snore guard mouthpiece instructions how to make a paper air sleep snore reviews on garcinia the end snoring mgs3 walkthrough ring for preventing snoring naturally long soft palate snoring remedies throat snoring cures devices to stop cure for snoring dogs normal mt washington pediatric sleep study sleep apnea affecting driving what can i do to stop snoring when i sleep youtube snoring wife lonehill johannesburg snoring medication australia snore sound effect free download chin strap snoring solution do anti snore pillows workaholics new season snore relief throat strips apnea mouthpiece dental how not to snore in public baby snoring causes sore sleep study cpt code for 2014 tips to stop someone snoring treatments no more snoring reviews of anti snore pillows stop snoring products boots apnea sleep masks snore guard anti-snoring device hudson swedish snore no more pillow review solutions for snoring husband driving me crazy fire at will stop snore ring review home remedies to help sleep at night sleep apnea mouth guard canada how long does rem sleep last how to help chronic snoring cure how to sleep through partner snoring treatments sleep study procedure codes snoring product of the year clips of indian snoring women pictures snoring dog cure for diarrhea how do i find out if i have a sleep disorder are anti snoring sprays safelite how to not snore yahoo mail dental snore guard ada code for implant how does anti snoring ring workshop how to stop snoring now naturally inducing british snoring & sleep apnea association what causes sleeping disorders beautyko snore stopper review anti snoring sprays indian stop snoring device ratings percentage sona anti snore pillow canada help with snoring partner natural snoring remedies home medical pillar procedure for snoring treatment anti snore device reviews evaluation tools how to stop mouth breathing when you sleep do dental devices work for sleep apnea clips of indian snoring women video opro mouth shield for sports apnea alarm troubleshooting preventing snoring boots for women snore guard dental code d2950 snoring mouth guards walgreens coupons icd 9 apnea sleep info black market online drugs sleep apnea device tongue and cheek how to stop a dog snoring remedy melatonin for circadian rhythm sleep disorder children snoring causes weight toddler excessive snoring my partner snores really loud fireworks how to not snore yahoo news brookstone anti-snore pillow video snore no more mouthpiece noiselezz and somnoguard dental sleep apnea devices costs what can i do about snoring pillow yoga for snoring stopping nose strips for snoring tesco bank what is apnea diving anti snoring methods of research how to prevent not to snore too much rem sleep disorder dream products sleep ez anti snoring pillows anti snoring chin strap walgreens snore mender discount snore chin strap walgreens jobs sleep apnea treatment scamschool how to use a body pillow for snoring most effective snore cure natural sleep apnea types snoring pillow cure for snoring nhs uk careers snoring diagrams of how to build snoring mask chin masks shel stop snoring mouth spray for pain methods of preventing snoring in pregnancy snore gone instructions not included reasons for heavy snoring causes breathe right snore relief throat strips-30 cthulhu snoring nose clips do they work anti snoring ring holland and barrett sign under your pillow to stop snoring does being overweight make you snore louder moderately severe obstructive sleep apnea best ear plugs to block snoring boots snoring relief oral strips stop your snoring naturally
Home BoB Documents Flood v. Kuhn

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 775 guests online

Atom RSS

Flood v. Kuhn PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 64
PoorBest 
Selection of Docs
Written by Court Ruling   
Sunday, 18 June 1972 12:00

407 U.S. 258

FLOOD v. KUHN ET AL.
CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT

No. 71-32.

Argued March 20, 1972
Decided June 19, 1972

Petitioner, a professional baseball player "traded" to another club without his previous knowledge or consent, brought this antitrust suit after being refused the right to make his own contract with another major league team, which is not permitted under the reserve system. The District Court rendered judgment in favor of respondents, and the Court of Appeals affirmed. Held: The longstanding exemption of professional baseball from the antitrust laws, Federal Baseball Club v. National League, 259 U.S. 200 (1922); Toolson v. New York Yankees, Inc., 346 U.S. 356 (1953), is an established aberration, in the light of the Court's holding that other interstate professional sports are not similarly exempt, but one in which Congress has acquiesced, and that is entitled to the benefit of stare decisis. Removal of the resultant inconsistency at this late date is a matter for legislative, not judicial, resolution. Pp. 269-285.

It is a century and a quarter since the New York Nine defeated the Knickerbockers 23 to 1 on Hoboken's [407 U.S. 258, 261] Elysian Fields June 19, 1846, with Alexander Jay Cartwright as the instigator and the umpire. The teams were amateur, but the contest marked a significant date in baseball's beginnings. That early game led ultimately to the development of professional baseball and its tightly organized structure.

And one recalls the appropriate reference to the "World Serious," attributed to Ring Lardner, Sr.; Ernest L. Thayer's "Casey at the Bat"; 4 the ring of "Tinker to [407 U.S. 258, 264] Evers to Chance"; 5 and all the other happenings, habits, and superstitions about and around baseball that made it the "national pastime" or, depending upon the point of view, "the great American tragedy." 6

The petitioner, Curtis Charles Flood, born in 1938, began his major league career in 1956 when he signed a contract with the Cincinnati Reds for a salary of $4,000 for the season. He had no attorney or agent to advise him on that occasion. He was traded to the St. Louis Cardinals before the 1958 season. Flood rose to fame as a center fielder with the Cardinals during the years 1958-1969. In those 12 seasons he compiled a batting average of .293. His best offensive season was 1967 when he achieved .335. He was .301 or better in six of the 12 St. Louis years. He participated in the 1964, 1967, and 1968 World Series. He played error less ball in the field in 1966, and once enjoyed 223 consecutive errorless games. Flood has received seven Golden Glove Awards. He was co-captain of his team from 1965-1969. He ranks among the 10 major league outfielders possessing the highest lifetime fielding averages. [407 U.S. 258, 265]

Flood declined to play for Philadelphia in 1970, despite a $100,000 salary offer, and he sat out the year. After the season was concluded, Philadelphia sold its rights to Flood to the Washington Senators. Washington and the petitioner were able to come to terms for 1971 at a salary of $110,000. 8 Flood started the season but, apparently because he was dissatisfied with his performance, he left the Washington club on April 27, early in the campaign. He has not played baseball since then.

On appeal, the Second Circuit felt "compelled to affirm." 443 F.2d 264, 265 (1971). It regarded the issue of state law as one of first impression, but concluded that the Commerce Clause precluded its application. Judge Moore added a concurring opinion in which he predicted, with respect to the suggested overruling of Federal Baseball and Toolson, that "there is no likelihood that such an event will occur." 9 443 F.2d, at 268, 272. [407 U.S. 258, 269]

A. Federal Baseball Club v. National League, 259 U.S. 200 (1922), was a suit for treble damages instituted by a member of the Federal League (Baltimore) against the National and American Leagues and others. The plaintiff obtained a verdict in the trial court, but the Court of Appeals reversed. The main brief filed by the plaintiff with this Court discloses that it was strenuously argued, among other things, that the business in which the defendants were engaged was interstate commerce; that the interstate relationship among the several clubs, located as they were in different States, was predominant; that organized baseball represented an investment of colossal wealth; that it was an engagement in moneymaking; that gate receipts were divided by agreement between the home club and the visiting club; and that the business of baseball was to be distinguished from the mere playing of the game as a sport for physical exercise and diversion. See also 259 U.S., at 201 -206.

"The business is giving exhibitions of base ball, which are purely state affairs. . . . But the fact that in order to give the exhibitions the Leagues must induce free persons to cross state lines and [407 U.S. 258, 270] must arrange and pay for their doing so is not enough to change the character of the business. . . . [T]he transport is a mere incident, not the essential thing. That to which it is incident, the exhibition, although made for money would not be called trade or commerce in the commonly accepted use of those words. As it is put by the defendants, personal effort, not related to production, is not a subject of commerce. That which in its consummation is not commerce does not become commerce among the States because the transportation that we have mentioned takes place. To repeat the illustrations given by the Court below, a firm of lawyers sending out a member to argue a case, or the Chautauqua lecture bureau sending out lecturers, does not engage in such commerce because the lawyer or lecturer goes to another State.

"If we are right the plaintiff's business is to be described in the same way and the restrictions by contract that prevented the plaintiff from getting players to break their bargains and the other conduct charged against the defendants were not an interference with commerce among the States." 259 U.S., at 208 -209. 10 [407 U.S. 258, 271]

B. Federal Baseball was cited a year later, and without disfavor, in another opinion by Mr. Justice Holmes for a unanimous Court. The complaint charged antitrust violations with respect to vaudeville bookings. It was held, however, that the claim was not frivolous and that the bill should not have been dismissed. Hart v. B. F. Keith Vaudeville Exchange, 262 U.S. 271 (1923). 11

In the years that followed, baseball continued to be subject to intermittent antitrust attack. The courts, however, rejected these challenges on the authority of Federal Baseball. In some cases stress was laid, although unsuccessfully, on new factors such as the development of radio and television with their substantial additional revenues to baseball. 12 For the most part, however, the Holmes opinion was generally and necessarily accepted as controlling authority. 13 And in the 1952 Report of the Subcommittee on Study of Monopoly Power of the House Committee on the Judiciary, H. R. Rep. No. 2002, 82d Cong., 2d Sess., 229, it was said, in conclusion:

"On the other hand the overwhelming preponderance of the evidence established baseball's need for some sort of reserve clause. Baseball's history shows that chaotic conditions prevailed when there was no reserve clause. Experience points to no feasible substitute to protect the integrity of the game or to guarantee a comparatively even competitive [407 U.S. 258, 273] struggle. The evidence adduced at the hearings would clearly not justify the enactment of legislation flatly condemning the reserve clause."

C. The Court granted certiorari, 345 U.S. 963 (1953), in the Toolson, Kowalski, and Corbett cases, cited in nn. 12 and 13, supra, and, by a short per curiam (Warren, C. J., and Black, Frankfurter, DOUGLAS, Jackson, Clark, and Minton, JJ.), affirmed the judgments of the respective courts of appeals in those three cases. Toolson v. New York Yankees, Inc., 346 U.S. 356 (1953). Federal Baseball was cited as holding "that the business of providing public baseball games for profit between clubs of professional baseball players was not within the scope of the federal antitrust laws," 346 U.S., at 357 , and:

". . . If the Toolson holding is to be expanded - or contracted - the appropriate remedy lies with Congress." 348 U.S., at 228 -230.

E. United States v. International Boxing Club, 348 U.S. 236 (1955), was a companion to Shubert and was decided the same day. This was a civil antitrust action against defendants engaged in the business of promoting professional championship boxing contests. Here again the District Court had dismissed the complaint in reliance upon Federal Baseball and Toolson. The Chief Justice observed that "if it were not for Federal Baseball and Toolson, we think that it would be too clear for dispute that the Government's allegations bring the defendants within the scope of the Act." 348 U.S., at 240 -241. He pointed out that the defendants relied on the two baseball cases but also would have been content with a more restrictive interpretation of them than the Shubert defendants, for the boxing defendants argued that the cases immunized only businesses that involve exhibitions of an athletic nature. The Court accepted neither argument. It again noted, 348 U.S., at 242 , that "Toolson neither overruled Federal Baseball nor necessarily reaffirmed all that was said in Federal Baseball." It stated:

"The controlling consideration in Federal Baseball and Hart was, instead, a very practical one - the degree of interstate activity involved in the particular business under review. It follows that stare decisis cannot help the defendants here; for, contrary to their argument, Federal Baseball did not hold that all businesses based on professional sports were outside the scope of the antitrust laws. The issue confronting us is, therefore, not whether a previously granted exemption should continue, [407 U.S. 258, 277] but whether an exemption should be granted in the first instance. And that issue is for Congress to resolve, not this Court." 348 U.S., at 243 .

The Court noted the presence then in Congress of various bills forbidding the application of the antitrust laws to "organized professional sports enterprises"; the holding of extensive hearings on some of these; subcommittee opposition; a postponement recommendation as to baseball; and the fact that "Congress thus left intact the then-existing coverage of the antitrust laws." 348 U.S., at 243 -244.

Mr. Justice Frankfurter, joined by Mr. Justice Minton, dissented. "It would baffle the subtlest ingenuity," he said, "to find a single differentiating factor between other sporting exhibitions . . . and baseball insofar as the conduct of the sport is relevant to the criteria or considerations by which the Sherman Law becomes applicable to a `trade or commerce.'" 348 U.S., at 248 . He went on:

This Court reversed with an opinion by Mr. Justice Clark. He said that the Court made its ruling in Toolson "because it was concluded that more harm would be done in overruling Federal Baseball than in upholding a ruling which at best was of dubious validity." 352 U.S., at 450 . He noted that Congress had not acted. He then said:

"All this, combined with the flood of litigation that would follow its repudiation, the harassment that would ensue, and the retroactive effect of such a decision, led the Court to the practical result that [407 U.S. 258, 279] it should sustain the unequivocal line of authority reaching over many years.

Mr. Justice Frankfurter dissented essentially for the reasons stated in his dissent in International Boxing, [407 U.S. 258, 280] 352 U.S., at 455 . Mr. Justice Harlan, joined by MR. JUSTICE BRENNAN, also dissented because he, too, was "unable to distinguish football from baseball." 352 U.S., at 456 . Here again the dissenting Justices did not call for the overruling of the baseball decisions. They merely could not distinguish the two sports and, out of respect for stare decisis, voted to affirm.

G. Finally, in Haywood v. National Basketball Assn., 401 U.S. 1204 (1971), MR. JUSTICE DOUGLAS, in his capacity as Circuit Justice, reinstated a District Court's injunction pendente lite in favor of a professional basketball player and said, "Basketball . . . does not enjoy exemption from the antitrust laws." 401 U.S., at 1205 . 15

I. Legislative proposals have been numerous and persistent. Since Toolson more than 50 bills have been introduced in Congress relative to the applicability or nonapplicability of the antitrust laws to baseball. 17 A few of these passed one house or the other. Those that did would have expanded, not restricted, the reserve system's exemption to other professional league sports. And the Act of Sept. 30, 1961, Pub. L. 87-331, 75 Stat. 732, and the merger addition thereto effected by the Act of Nov. 8, 1966. Pub. L. 89-800, 6 (b), [407 U.S. 258, 282] 80 Stat. 1515, 15 U.S.C. 1291-1295, were also expansive rather than restrictive as to antitrust exemption. 18

4. Other professional sports operating interstate - football, [407 U.S. 258, 283] boxing, basketball, and, presumably, hockey 19 and golf 20 - are not so exempt.

This emphasis and this concern are still with us. We continue to be loath, 50 years after Federal Baseball and almost two decades after Toolson, to overturn those cases judicially when Congress, by its positive inaction, [407 U.S. 258, 284] has allowed those decisions to stand for so long and, far beyond mere inference and implication, has clearly evinced a desire not to disapprove them legislatively.

The conclusion we have reached makes it unnecessary for us to consider the respondents' additional argument that the reserve system is a mandatory subject of collective bargaining and that federal labor policy therefore exempts the reserve system from the operation of federal antitrust laws. 22

"Without re-examination of the underlying issues, the [judgment] below [is] affirmed on the authority of Federal Baseball Club of Baltimore v. National League of Professional Baseball Clubs, supra, so far as that decision determines that Congress had no intention of including the business of baseball within the scope of the federal antitrust laws." 346 U.S., at 357 .

[ Footnote 2 ] See generally The Baseball Encyclopedia (1969); L. Ritter, The Glory of Their Times (1966); 1 & 2 H. Seymour, Baseball (1960, 1971); 1 & 2 D. Voigt, American Baseball (1966, 1970).

[ Footnote 3 ] These are names only from earlier years. By mentioning some, one risks unintended omission of others equally celebrated.

[ Footnote 4 ] Millions have known and enjoyed baseball. One writer knowledgeable in the field of sports almost assumed that everyone did until, one day, he discovered otherwise:

[ Footnote 7 ] Concededly supported by the Major League Baseball Players Association, the players' collective-bargaining representative. Tr. of Oral Arg. 12.

[ Footnote 8 ] The parties agreed that Flood's participating in baseball in 1971 would be without prejudice to his case.

[ Footnote 9 ] "And properly so. Baseball's welfare and future should not be for politically insulated interpreters of technical antitrust statutes but rather should be for the voters through their elected representatives. If baseball is to be damaged by statutory regulation, let the congressman face his constituents the next November and also face the consequences of his baseball voting record." 443 F.2d, at 272.

Cf. Judge Friendly's comments in Salerno v. American League, 429 F.2d 1003, 1005 (CA2 1970), cert. denied, sub nom. Salerno v. Kuhn, 400 U.S. 1001 (1971):

"We freely acknowledge our belief that Federal Baseball was not one of Mr. Justice Holmes' happiest days, that the rationale of Toolson is extremely dubious and that, to use the Supreme Court's [407 U.S. 258, 269] own adjectives, the distinction between baseball and other professional sports is `unrealistic,' `inconsistent' and `illogical.'. . . While we should not fall out of our chairs with surprise at the news that Federal Baseball and Toolson had been overruled, we are not at all certain the Court is ready to give them a happy despatch."

[ Footnote 10 ] "What really saved baseball, legally at least, for the next half century was the protective canopy spread over it by the United States Supreme Court's decision in the Baltimore Federal League anti-trust suit against Organized Baseball in 1922. In it Justice Holmes, speaking for a unanimous court, ruled that the business of giving baseball exhibitions for profit was not `trade or commerce in the commonly-accepted use of those words' because `personal effort, not related to production, is not a subject of commerce'; nor was it interstate, because the movement of ball clubs across state lines was merely `incidental' to the business. It should be noted that, contrary to what many believe, Holmes did call baseball a business; time and again those who have not troubled to read the text of the decision have claimed incorrectly that the court said baseball was a sport and not a business." 2 H. Seymour, Baseball 420 (1971).

[ Footnote 11 ] On remand of the Hart case the trial court dismissed the complaint at the close of the evidence. The Second Circuit affirmed on the ground that the plaintiff's evidence failed to establish that the interstate transportation was more than incidental. 12 F.2d 341 (1926). This Court denied certiorari, 273 U.S. 703 (1926).

[ Footnote 12 ] Toolson v. New York Yankees, Inc., 101 F. Supp. 93 (SD Cal. 1951), aff'd, 200 F.2d 198 (CA9 1952); Kowalski v. Chandler, 202 F.2d 413 (CA6 1953). See Salerno v. American League, 429 F.2d 1003 (CA2 1970), cert, denied, sub nom. Salerno v. Kuhn, 400 U.S. 1001 (1971). But cf. Gardella v. Chandler, 172 F.2d 402 (CA2 1949) (this case, we are advised, was subsequently settled); Martin v. National League Baseball Club, 174 F.2d 917 (CA2 1949).

[ Footnote 13 ] Corbett v. Chandler, 202 F.2d 428 (Ca6 1953); Portland Baseball Club, Inc. v. Baltimore Baseball Club, Inc., 282 F.2d 680 (CA9 1960); Niemiec v. Seattle Rainier Baseball Club, Inc., 67 F. Supp. 705 (WD Wash. 1946). See State v. Milwaukee Braves, Inc., 31 Wis. 2d 699, 144 N. W. 2d 1, cert. denied, 385 U.S. 990 (1966).

[ Footnote 14 ] The case's final chapter is International Boxing Club v. United States, 358 U.S. 242 (1959).

[ Footnote 15 ] See also Denver Rockets v. All-Pro Management, Inc., 325 F. Supp. 1049, 1060 (CD Cal. 1971); Washington Professional Basketball Corp. v. National Basketball Assn., 147 F. Supp. 154 (SDNY 1956).

[ Footnote 16 ] Neville, Baseball and the Antitrust Laws, 16 Fordham L. Rev. 208 (1947); Eckler, Baseball - Sport or Commerce?, 17 U. Chi. L. Rev. 56 (1949); Comment, Monopsony in Manpower: Organized Baseball Meets the Antitrust Laws, 62 Yale L. J. 576 (1953); P. Gregory, The Baseball Player, An Economic Study, c. 19 (1956); Note, The Super Bowl and the Sherman Act: Professional Team Sports and the Antitrust Laws, 81 Harv. L. Rev. 418 (1967); The Supreme Court, 1953 Term, 68 Harv. L. Rev. 105, 136-138 (1954); The Supreme Court, 1956 Term, 71 Harv. L. Rev. 94, 170-173 (1957); Note, 32 Va. L. Rev. 1164 (1946); Note, 24 Notre Dame Law. 372 (1949); Note, 53 Col. L. Rev. 242 (1953); Note, 22 U. Kan. City L. Rev. 173 (1954); Note, 25 Miss. L. J. 270 (1954); Note, 29 N. Y. U. L. Rev. 213 (1954); Note, 105 U. Pa. L. Rev. 110 (1956); Note, 32 Texas L. Rev. 890 (1954); Note, 35 B. U. L. Rev. 447 (1955); Note, 57 Col. L. Rev. 725 (1957); Note, 23 Geo. Wash. L. Rev. 606 (1955); Note, 1 How. L. J. 281 (1955); Note, 26 Miss. L. J. 271 (1955); Note, 9 Sw. L. J. 369 (1955); Note, 29 Temple L. Q. 103 (1955); Note, 29 Tul. L. Rev. 793 (1955); Note, 62 Dick. [407 U.S. 258, 281] L. Rev. 96 (1957); Note, 11 Sw. L. J. 516 (1957); Note, 36 N.C. L. Rev. 315 (1958); Note, 35 Fordham L. Rev. 350 (1966); Note, 8 B. C. Ind. & Com. L. Rev. 341 (1967); Note, 13 Wayne L. Rev. 417 (1967); Note, 2 Rutgers-Camden L. J. 302 (1970); Note, 8 San Diego L. Rev. 92 (1970); Note, 12 B. C. Ind. & Com. L. Rev. 737 (1971); Note, 12 Wm. & Mary L. Rev. 859 (1971).

[ Footnote 17 ] Hearings on H. R. 5307 et al. before the Antitrust Subcommittee of the House Committee on the Judiciary, 85th Cong., 1st Sess. (1957); Hearings on H. R. 10378 and S. 4070 before the Subcommittee on Antitrust and Monopoly of the Senate Committee on the Judiciary, 85th Cong., 2d Sess. (1958); Hearings on H. R. 2370 et al. before the Antitrust Subcommittee of the House Committee on the Judiciary, 86th Cong., 1st Sess. (1959) (not printed); Hearings on S. 616 and S. 886 before the Subcommittee on Antitrust and Monopoly of the Senate Committee on the Judiciary, 86th Cong., 1st Sess. (1959); Hearings on S. 3483 before the Subcommittee on Antitrust and Monopoly of the Senate Committee on the Judiciary, 86th Cong., 2d Sess. (1960); Hearings on S. 2391 before the Subcommittee on Antitrust and Monopoly of the Senate Committee on the Judiciary, 88th Cong., 2d Sess. (1964); S. Rep. No. 1303, 88th Cong., 2d Sess. (1964); Hearings on S. 950 before the Subcommittee on Antitrust and Monopoly of the Senate Committee on the Judiciary, 89th Cong., 1st Sess. (1965); S. Rep. No. 462, 89th Cong., 1st Sess. (1965). Bills introduced in the 92d Cong., 1st Sess., and bearing on the subject are S. 2599, S. 2616, H. R. 2305, H. R. 11033, and H. R. 10825.

[ Footnote 18 ] Title 15 U.S.C. 1294 reads:

[ Footnote 20 ] Deesen v. Professional Golfers' Assn., 358 F.2d 165 (CA9), cert. denied, 385 U.S. 846 (1966).

[ Footnote 21 ] See Brief for Respondent in Federal Baseball, No. 204, O. T. 1921, p. 67, and in Toolson, No. 18, O. T. 1953, p. 30. See also State v. Milwaukee Braves, Inc., 31 Wis. 2d 699, 144 N. W. 2d 1, cert. denied, 385 U.S. 990 (1966).

[ Footnote 22 ] See Jacobs & Winter, Antitrust Principles and Collective Bargaining by Athletes: Of Superstars in Peonage, 81 Yale L. J. 1 (1971), suggesting present-day irrelevancy of the antitrust issue.

In 1922 the Court had a narrow, parochial view of commerce. With the demise of the old landmarks of that era, particularly United States v. Knight Co., 156 U.S. 1 , Hammer v. Dagenhart, 247 U.S. 251 , and Paul v. Virginia, 8 Wall. 168, the whole concept of commerce has changed.

Under the modern decisions such as Mandeville Island Farms v. American Crystal Sugar Co., 334 U.S. 219 ; United States v. Darby, 312 U.S. 100 ; Wickard v. Filburn, 317 U.S. 111 ; United States v. South-Eastern Underwriters Assn., 322 U.S. 533 , the power of Congress was recognized as broad enough to reach all phases of the vast operations of our national industrial system. [407 U.S. 258, 287] An industry so dependent on radio and television as is baseball and gleaning vast interstate revenues (see H. R. Rep. No. 2002, 82d Cong., 2d Sess., 4, 5 (1952)) would be hard put today to say with the Court in the Federal Baseball Club case that baseball was only a local exhibition, not trade or commerce.

If congressional inaction is our guide, we should rely upon the fact that Congress has refused to enact bills broadly exempting professional sports from antitrust regulation. 3 H. R. Rep. No. 2002, 82d Cong., 2d Sess. [407 U.S. 258, 288] (1952). The only statutory exemption granted by Congress to professional sports concerns broadcasting rights. 15 U.S.C. 1291-1295. I would not ascribe a broader exemption through inaction than Congress has seen fit to grant explicitly.

There can be no doubt "that were we considering the question of baseball for the first time upon a clean slate" 4 we would hold it to be subject to federal antitrust regulation. Radovich v. National Football League, 352 U.S. 445, 452 . The unbroken silence of Congress should not prevent us from correcting our own mistakes.

[ Footnote 1 ] While I joined the Court's opinion in Toolson v. New York Yankees, Inc., 346 U.S. 356 , I have lived to regret it; and I would now correct what I believe to be its fundamental error.

[ Footnote 2 ] Had this same group boycott occurred in another industry, Klor's, Inc. v. Broadway-Hale Stores, Inc., 359 U.S. 207 ; United States v. Shubert, 348 U.S. 222 ; or even in another sport, Haywood v. National Basketball Assn., 401 U.S. 1204 (DOUGLAS, J., in chambers); Radovich v. National Football League, 352 U.S. 445 ; United States v. International Boxing Club, 348 U.S. 236 ; we would have no difficulty in sustaining petitioner's claim.

[ Footnote 3 ] The Court's reliance upon congressional inaction disregards the wisdom of Helvering v. Hallock, 309 U.S. 106, 119 -121, where we said:

"Nor does want of specific Congressional repudiations . . . serve as an implied instruction by Congress to us not to reconsider, in the light of new experience . . . those decisions . . . . It would require very persuasive circumstances enveloping Congressional silence to [407 U.S. 258, 288] debar this Court from re-examining its own doctrines. . . . Various considerations of parliamentary tactics and strategy might be suggested as reasons for the inaction of . . . Congress, but they would only be sufficient to indicate that we walk on quicksand when we try to find in the absence of corrective legislation a controlling legal principle."

And see United States v. South-Eastern Underwriters Assn., 322 U.S. 533, 556 -561.

[ Footnote 4 ] This case gives us for the first time a full record showing the reserve clause in actual operation.

To non-athletes it might appear that petitioner was virtually enslaved by the owners of major league baseball clubs who bartered among themselves for his services. But, athletes know that it was not servitude that bound petitioner to the club owners; it was the reserve system. The essence of that system is that a player is bound to the club with which he first signs a contract for the rest of his playing days. 2 He cannot escape from the club except by retiring, and he cannot prevent the club from assigning his contract to any other club.

Petitioner brought this action in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York. He alleged, among other things, that the reserve system was an unreasonable restraint of trade in violation of [407 U.S. 258, 290] federal antitrust laws. 3 The District Court thought itself bound by prior decisions of this Court and found for the respondents after a full trial. 309 F. Supp. 793 (1970). The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit affirmed. 443 F.2d 264 (1971). We granted certiorari on October 19, 1971, 404 U.S. 880 , in order to take a further look at the precedents relied upon by the lower courts.

This is a difficult case because we are torn between the principle of stare decisis and the knowledge that the decisions in Federal Baseball Club v. National League, 259 U.S. 200 (1922), and Toolson v. New York Yankees, Inc., 346 U.S. 356 (1953), are totally at odds with more recent and better reasoned cases.

In Federal Baseball Club, a team in the Federal League brought an antitrust action against the National and American Leagues and others. In his opinion for a unanimous Court, Mr. Justice Holmes wrote that the business being considered was "giving exhibitions of base ball, which are purely state affairs." 259 U.S., at 208 . Hence, the Court held that baseball was not within the purview of the antitrust laws. Thirty-one years later, the Court reaffirmed this decision, without reexamining it, in Toolson, a one-paragraph per curiam opinion. Like this case, Toolson involved an attack on the reserve system. The Court said:

"The business has . . . been left for thirty years to develop, on the understanding that it was not [407 U.S. 258, 291] subject to existing antitrust legislation. The present cases ask us to overrule the prior decision and, with retrospective effect, hold the legislation applicable. We think that if there are evils in this field which now warrant application to it of the antitrust laws it should be by legislation." Id., at 357.

"Antitrust laws in general, and the Sherman Act in particular, are the Magna Carta of free enterprise. They are as important to the preservation of economic freedom and our free-enterprise system as the Bill of Rights is to the protection of our fundamental personal freedoms. . . . Implicit in such freedom is the notion that it cannot be foreclosed with respect to one sector of the economy [407 U.S. 258, 292] because certain private citizens or groups believe that such foreclosure might promote greater competition in a more important sector of the economy." United States v. Topco Associates, Inc., 405 U.S. 596, 610 (1972).

This Court has faced the interrelationship between the antitrust laws and the labor laws before. The decisions make several things clear. First, "benefits to organized labor cannot be utilized as a cat's-paw to pull employer's chestnuts out of the antitrust fires." United States v. Women's Sportswear Manufacturers Assn., 336 U.S. 460, 464 (1949). See also Allen Bradley Co. v. Local Union No. 3, 325 U.S. 797 (1945). Second, the very nature of a collective-bargaining agreement mandates that the parties be able to "restrain" trade to a greater degree than management could do unilaterally. United States v. Hutcheson, 312 U.S. 219 (1941); United Mine Workers v. Pennington, 381 U.S. 657 (1965); Amalgamated Meat Cutters v. Jewel Tea, 381 U.S. 676 (1965); cf., Teamsters Union v. Oliver, 358 U.S. 283 (1959). Finally, it is clear that some cases can be resolved only by examining the purposes and the competing interests of the labor and antitrust statutes and by striking a balance.

It is apparent that none of the prior cases is precisely in point. They involve union-management agreements that work to the detriment of management's competitors. In this case, petitioner urges that the reserve system works to the detriment of labor. [407 U.S. 258, 295]

[ Footnote 2 ] As MR. JUSTICE BLACKMUN points out, the reserve system is not novel. It has been employed since 1887. See Metropolitan Exhibition Co. v. Ewing, 42 F. 198, 202-204 (CC SDNY 1890). The club owners assert that it is necessary to preserve effective competition and to retain fan interest. The players do not agree and argue that the reserve system is overly restrictive. Before this lawsuit was instituted, the players refused to agree that the reserve system should be a part of the collective-bargaining contract. Instead, the owners and players agreed that the reserve system would temporarily remain in effect while they jointly investigated possible changes. Their activity along these lines has halted pending the outcome of this suit.

[ Footnote 3 ] Petitioner also alleged a violation of state antitrust laws, state civil rights laws, and of the common law, and claimed that he was forced into peonage and involuntary servitude in violation of the Thirteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution. Because I believe that federal antitrust laws govern baseball, I find that state law has been pre-empted in this area. Like the lower courts, I do not believe that there has been a violation of the Thirteenth Amendment.

[ Footnote 4 ] In the past this Court has not hesitated to change its view as to what constitutes interstate commerce. Compare United States v. Knight Co., 156 U.S. 1 (1895), with Mandeville Island Farms v. American Crystal Sugar Co., 334 U.S. 219 (1948), and United States v. Darby, 312 U.S. 100 (1941).

[ Footnote 6 ] The lower courts did not reach the question of whether, assuming the antitrust laws apply, they have been violated. This should be considered on remand.

[ Footnote 7 ] Cf. United States v. Hutcheson, 312 U.S. 219 (1941).

[ Footnote 8 ] Jacobs & Winter, Antitrust Principles and Collective Bargaining by Athletes: Of Superstars in Peonage, 81 Yale L. J. 1, 22 (1971). [407 U.S. 258, 297]

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?