best credit cards for 650 credit score british airway chase credit card application canadian credit card with lowest interest rate capital one retail credit cards asia miles credit card philippines small new business credit cards hhonors credit card american express american express travel miles credit card aaa financial services credit card login nab internet credit card payment bmi baby credit card application top ways to pay off credit card debt square credit card printer canadian tire credit cards applications free dating sites no credit card australia debit card vs credit card rewards no foreign transaction fee credit card 2012 can pay my flagstar mortgage credit card which credit cards have the best foreign exchange rates credit card design ideas foreign currency transaction fee credit card india cimb credit card redemption travel credit card reviews average college student debt credit cards get credit card swiping machine india credit card payment processors canada sears credit card bill payment address credit card college student bad credit how to activate wells fargo credit card apply for a lowes business credit card whats the best credit card credit card number generator with cvv online credit card transactions for small business can you pay your gap credit card store show roberto carlos credit card hall credit card reader iphone 4 uk hsbc student credit card hk centon 128gb datastick credit card usb flash drive can pay used car credit card credit card security breach 2011 can you buy florida lottery tickets with a credit card tips paying down credit cards preloaded credit cards walmart compare credit card balance transfer offers calculator aluminum credit card case wholesale reviews on first premier bank credit card best benefits of credit cards stop credit card access checks credit card free flight southwest american express prepaid credit card reviews different types of credit card companies paypal send money using credit card open credit card online how to pay off credit card debt universal american express credit card login new bad credit credit card offers paying federal estimated taxes with credit card best credit card machine requirements for discover student credit card pay auto loan with credit card chase suntrust secured credit card card consolidation credit debt payment versus best student credit card australia suntrust bank credit card login credit cards for people with bad credit ratings repair ips credit card online payment stop united mileage plus credit card offers juniper credit card barclays bank delaware volkswagen credit card login apply imagine credit card furniture credit cards for bad credit spirit airlines credit card application status macys american express credit card sign in close credit card accounts without hurting credit score apply sbi corporate credit card natwest credit card lost pin number regulates credit card companies uk online credit card payments for business average american household debt credit cards bank america cash reward credit card review citi govt credit card payment how do credit cards companies make money guaranteed credit cards with instant approval aa credit card account login tips for getting out of credit card debt 40 000 united miles credit card credit card processing fee owl credit card magnifier cheap car rental johannesburg no credit card ge online services credit card login kohls charge card credit limit best banks with secured credit cards the history of credit cards credit card bailout obama credit card foreign transaction fee bank america mango credit card reviews credit card number length reviews delta airlines credit cards types of american express credit cards tire kingdom credit card customer service the children;s place credit card payment online best credit card points program university credit card payments college student credit card with cosigner how to pay hdfc credit card bill from citibank account negotiating with credit card companies + settlement ways to get cash from credit card case mate iphone 4 credit card holder apply lowe;s credit card get lower apr chase credit card tjx rewards credit card cancel my chase credit card account frequent flyer credit card qantas blue star credit card processing can get money order credit card walmart toys r us credit card number phone number ann taylor loft credit card application status check visa credit card balance what is the credit limit on a black american express card can we transfer money from credit card to credit card pay mortgage with credit card check the avenue credit card services unsecured credit cards for people with low credit fat wallet credit card thread guaranteed approval credit card bad credit smart money best credit cards 2009 what is a cid code on credit card ge credit cards india first credit card company to introduce the multi-application smart card what is the best credit card for a college student with no credit history send money with credit card american express credit cards no balance transfer fee low apr credit card easy payment plan pros cons debt consolidation credit cards can you pay mortgage with credit card bank of america how to pay navy federal credit card hsbc credit card website how to make itunes account without credit card on iphone 4 using credit card advantages and disadvantages balance transfer credit cards for bad credit how to change credit card on itunes from ipad 2 citibank credit card payment centers delhi how to find sort code and account number on credit card bpi credit card application follow up how does credit card info get stolen apply for chase visa credit card new york & co credit card credit card dimensions inches how to get out of credit card debt faster hack rfid enabled credit card steal money cheap hyatt credit card uk can you apply for two credit cards in the same day pay belk credit card online does being denied for a credit card lower your credit score send my wells fargo credit card payments best credit card for foreign transaction fees address gap credit card payments loans for bad credit and no debit card best 0 interest credit card deals how to pay credit card bill online hdfc with other bank how do credit cards work minimum payment 1st premier bank credit card phone number can i pay my bank of america credit card over the phone get all three credit scores free without credit card student credit card instant approval can you ask credit card companies to freeze interest how to get out of a credit card machine lease credit cards rebuilding credit after bankruptcy can create apple id without credit card details wireless credit card machine for android hdfc track your credit card status visa aaa credit card login how to apply for add on credit card in hdfc what is the lowest apr credit card applying walmart credit card online wells fargo bobs furniture credit card payment chase travel plus credit card can college students get credit cards suze orman credit card tips paypal credit card address verification private label credit cards wells fargo pre paid credit card hhgregg ge credit card login american credit card solutions bbb average interest rate credit cards now bad credit history credit card 5 cash back credit card discover best credit cards for miles rewards npc credit card processing company payment credit card debt settlement forum credit card information stolen psn hack american express bank credit card india how do you pay bank of america credit card online wachovia credit card minimum payment free credit card clip art logos halifax credit card online register barclaycard initial credit card application prepaid credit cards help rebuild credit median credit card debt american households zero city bank credit card uk prepaid credit cards that build your credit credit cards for first time users credit cards citibank singapore credit card number generator free software download credit cards does qvc accept my credit card keeps getting declined online best credit card offers balance transfers 2011 customer reviews on chase freedom credit card pay mortgage credit card wells fargo business credit cards with best rewards best credit cards transfer balances 2011 does mn state fair take credit cards best credit cards indian nyco credit card payment ent federal credit union credit card leather credit card wallet uk boa secured credit card status what do you need to apply for a business credit card first credit card no credit history no annual fee citi how many numbers does a credit card have in it zero balance transfer credit card offers prepaid credit card foreign travel state farm credit card rating chase credit card 0 transfer balance how to buy credit card numbers online google search credit card numbers hdfc credit card indiatimes offer small business accepting credit card online capital one custom credit cards old credit card debt in florida costco business credit card benefits aopa credit card benefits credit card scanner for android what are the best cashback credit cards what are the costs and pitfalls of using credit cards and debit cards low credit score credit cards credit cards fixed interest rates 0 credit card balance transfers purchases which credit card is best for balance transfer murphy usa walmart credit card citibank cash back credit card world of warcraft credit card redemption can you get a chase credit card with no credit best buy credit card log page the children;s place credit card application credit card debt forgiveness act 2009 hsbc credit card sign in page pay down high credit cards direct merchant bank credit card login usa credit cards chip pin credit card acquirer issuer should use credit card these checks pay with 2 credit cards best buy bowflex credit card payment how to check visa credit card balance online do prepaid credit cards help build credit freedom first credit card login credit cards 0 balance transfers no transaction fee schwab credit card international fee how many credit cards for good credit score bank of america credit card cover rental car insurance itunes no credit card option sapphire credit card login government citi visa credit card regulation z affects credit card issuers in which of the following ways uob credit card advance cash pay best buy credit card online make paypal without credit card bank account direct merchant credit card processing get cash credit card without pin sample authorization letter to pick up credit card; how to pay your amazon credit card credit cards ratings apply for credit cards with low credit score hsbc credit card services complaints sears credit card discount psn credit card numbers for sale suntrust credit card application lowes ge money bank credit card close citibank credit card account online my citibank credit card statement online walmart visa credit card login canadian credit card with no foreign currency transaction fee hsbc credit card cancellation credit card shopping cart wordpress mac compatible usb credit card reader axis bank titanium credit card offers capital one credit card for no credit history blue sky american express credit card reviews best reward credit cards 2012 travel new credit card laws canada 2011 subprime credit cards capital one best credit cards small business rewards offers federal law credit card refunds axis bank credit card bill payment online maybank credit card promotion malaysia credit cards balance transfer 0 interest no fee paypal charge to pay with credit card how much does quickbooks credit card processing cost chase credit card abuse can you get free credit report without credit card hsbc credit card foreign exchange rate delta skymiles credit card upgrade from gold to platinum uob debit card credit limit can i transfer a credit card balance to another person credit cards without international exchange fees do u need credit card paypal account accept credit cards cell phone paypal car care one credit card phone number target visa credit card payment online best small business credit cards miles credit card to build credit history credit cards with no deposit for bad credit apply for credit card with bad credit uk best credit card processors us toyota credit card services how to apply for a disney visa credit card american express credit card login student credit cards with bad credit/no credit walmart credit card services phone number pay off credit card or pay down mortgage business credit cards uk continental credit cards chase not using a credit card with itunes names different credit card companies credit score do need get visa black card spend get unsecured credit card no credit check citibank credit cards apply phone top cash back credit cards uk how does high credit card balance affect my credit score many credit card transactions per day uk hdfc titanium credit card offers 2012 credit card processing for new small business online access my credit card ann taylor loft fnb credit card travel insurance palais royal credit card login nordstrom credit card application credit card bill payment through debit card npc credit card services bank of america credit card account agreement does pnc bank offer secured credit cards sony credit card login capital one calculator how long to pay off credit card longest credit card 0 purchases credit card imprinter slips best airline miles credit cards 2011 publix employees federal credit union credit card aspire visa credit card application cancel chase credit card online credit card reward programs taxable credit card promotions november 2012 happens my credit card debt if file bankruptcy will a magnetic money clip ruin my credit card how does paypal work with my credit card credit card wallets/holders credit card avs verification valid credit card numbers and cvv numbers best iphone credit card reader chase credit card services contact phone number cabela credit card payment credit card payoff calculator formula get free credit card machine instant reply credit card application address for chase bank credit card payments axis bank credit card online shopping offers leather credit card wallets uk credit card approval criteria fee free credit card transfers store credit card details law ge money bank rooms to go credit card icici credit card online payment icici bank santander credit card login problems student discover card bad credit merrill lynch credit card application status obama credit card relief act www.shell credit card.account on line.com what credit card should i get if i have bad credit commonwealth bank gold credit card awards best credit cards for below average credit staples credit card online bill pay new york and company credit card credit score minimum credit score for credit card best credit cards balance transfers purchases do you need use your credit card build credit can you get student credit card bad credit credit cards in europe problems chase credit card lost or stolen alaska airlines rewards credit card access group credit card processing discover credit card status application lucky credit card redeem rewards points hdfc credit cards apply for a credit card rbs hdfc credit card online payment billdesk credit card default rate statistics how do i cancel my american eagle credit card pros and cons of using credit or debit cards aa miles credit card southwest airlines credit card review credit card online banking bank of america should i pay off credit cards with student loans ba american express credit card review shopping online credit card safety chase change credit card pin household bank credit cards good bank of america online credit card account access legacy visa credit card online what is 3 digit code on back of credit card credit card paper application can you pay with your credit card through paypal credit card american express bangladesh how can i view my citibank credit card statement online average credit card rate how do you cancel a credit card order can you pay bills with credit cards if credit card application denied maybank credit card advance cash pay my credit card bill online bank america credit card processing software pc hsbc best buy credit card online payment united mileage plus credit card account login kotak credit card statement online will wells fargo lower my credit card interest rate discover more card limited credit history citibank credit card default india average american credit card debt 2008 compromised credit card accept card credit internet over delta gold credit card sign up free apple id without credit card paying federal taxes online by credit card using someone else;s credit card without getting caught bad credit cards uk instant approval apply disneyland credit card easy to qualify store credit cards first time credit card uk cancellation of debt credit card tax usair credit card review student credit card applications online small business gas credit card credit cardholders bill of rights wiki chevron texaco credit card payment online diners club credit card sg american express foreign exchange rates credit cards cancel sleepys credit card money order from post office credit card total credit card debt apply online for barclays bank credit card capital one credit card review 2012 program credit card machine card credit bcr best mile credit card offers davids bridal credit card reviews lost credit card citibank india credit card comparison chart 2012 how long will it take to pay off my credit card formula best credit cards cash advance online advantages and disadvantages of using a credit card best credit card for us airways miles hdfc credit card swipe machine buy bitcoins instantly with credit card young money credit card credit card assistance program benefits how long does it take to get a credit card after approval kotak credit card customer care number ahmedabad rbc bank credit card login united credit card chase bank guaranteed credit card approval bad credit unsecured discover student credit card with no credit history ways cut down credit card debt credit card formula excel american express credit card merchant services 76 credit card union 76 phone number to call to stop credit card offers capital one credit card approval process do credit card miles rewards work yamaha motor credit card payment hsbc southwest visa credit card login how to get an apple id without a credit card 1st premier credit card payment address apply for student credit cards with no credit credit card payments via iphone uk barclay initial credit card review compare credit cards balance transfer offers td credit card application iphone asking credit card free app credit cards with no credit limit benefits of accepting credit cards using credit option your debit card what do you call the 3 digit code on the back of a credit card money magazine most rewarding credit cards can i use my bank of america debit card as a credit card how to use a prepaid credit card online purchase credit card machine hdfc visa gold - personal credit card best rate credit cards processing pci compliance credit card transactions unsecured credit card help rebuild credit yamaha credit card american express credit card benefits
Home All Articles By the Numbers: A Breakdown of the '08 Salary Arbitration

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 874 guests online

Atom RSS

By the Numbers: A Breakdown of the '08 Salary Arbitration PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 4
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Maury Brown   
Monday, 25 February 2008 22:00

A Biz of Baseball ExclusiveA Look Inside Salary Arbitration. Who Won. Who Lost. And, How Players Nearly Always Come Out Ahead

Most would say 1974 or 1975 was the most important for the players.

’74 represents the year that Jim “Catfish” Hunter was declared a free agent after Charlie Finley was found to be in breach of contract after not deferring part of Hunter’s salary and placing it in an annuity. The ensuing bidding war for Hunter showed just how much money owners were willing to throw at a free agent, if the shackles of the reserve system were thrown off.

’75 represents the year that Andy Messersmith and Dave McNally played their part in the historic Peter Seitz ruling in which the reserve clause was removed from baseball, and free agency became what is now, a permanent part of Major League Baseball.

Both are key points in history. Both are defined by Marvin Miller, Dick Moss and the Players’ Association. Both are watershed moments that redefined the rights of players, and by extension, the amount of money in salaries they would make. But, it is really 1973 that is Miller’s defining moment.

In 1973 salary arbitration was implemented in MLB, and since then has been a boon to the players, a thorn in the side of general managers, and a drain on owners’ wallets.

The system works thusly:

A player of over 2 years of service time (the CBA defines one full year as a total of 172 days of Major League credited service) can file for salary arbitration (see a listing of those that filed for salary arbitration this year), and at a given date on the calendar (this year it was January 18), if the parties have not yet reached a deal, the club and player exchange salary figures for what they wish to pay, or be paid, for the following year (see all the figures exchanged for 2008). If a deal is not reached by the club and player, then both sides present their case at a hearing before a panel of three arbitrators, which then rules whether the player figure or the club figure will be paid to the player over the next season. There is no in-between. It is either one, or the other.

Against that backdrop, more and more, deals are struck before hearings take place. In either case, the clubs almost always come out on the bad side of the deals.

Each year, I go through and examine all players that exchanged figures with the respective clubs and see who won, who lost, and when you think about it, who really lost while winning. Here are some details around the 2008 salary arbitration class:

Select Read More to see a Breakdown of this Year's Salary Arbitration Class

Salary Arbitration Details2008 Salary Arbitration Facts and Figures

Here’s some raw figures regarding the arbitration class of 2008. The figures are based on my analysis of the 48 players that exchanged figures with their clubs, with some additional data through The Associated Press.

(select the image to the left to see details for the 48 players that exchanged figures):

  • Increase in Salaries for the 110 players that Filed for Arbitration from Last Season: 120 percent.
  • Average Salary Increase for all 110 Players that Filed for Arbitration: An increase from $1.38 million to $3.04 million, was up from 106 percent last year and the highest since a 123 percent rise in 2005. The average rose from $3.01 million last year but was below the record $3.26 million set in 2004.
  • Multi-year Contracts for the 110 players that Filed for Arbitration: Sixteen players received multiyear contracts, two more than last year and the most since 17 in 2002.
  • Multi-year contracts for the 48 players the Exchanged Figures: Out of the sixteen total players that got multi-year contracts, ten of them were part of the pool that exchanged figures (Betancourt, Cano, Chavez, Cuddyer, Greene, Molina, Phillips, Rauch, Sanchez, Soriano)
  • Increase in salaries for the 48 players that filed for arbitration from last season: 220 percent.
  • Total salaries paid out to the 48 players that exchanged figures: $136,075,000
  • Average salary of the 48 players that exchanged figures for 2008: $2,834,896 , down from $2,853,214 last season.
  • Number of players that went hearing with their clubs: 8 (Clubs winning 6)
  • Historical Scorecard (From 1974, current to 2008): 485 hearings with owners winning 280 compared to players winning 205 case, or 57.73 percent of hearings in favor of owners.
  • Largest salary increases from last year (base salary):

Ryan Howard whose 2007 salary was $900,000, but sees it skyrocket to $10,000,000 by his winning salary arbitration hearing with the Phillies, an increase of 1,011 percent from last season. Howard is followed by Garrett Atkins (2007 salary: $400,000, 2008 salary $4,387,500, or an increase of 997 percent), and Brad Hawpe of the Rockies (2007 salary: $403,000, 2008 salary $3,925,000, or an increase of 874 percent) Chien-Ming Wang of the Yankees (2007 salary: $489,500, 2008 salary $4,000,000, or an increase of 717 percent by way of Yankees winning salary arbitration hearing), and Kevin Youkilis of the Red Sox (2007 salary: $424,500, 2008 salary $3,000,000, or an increase of 607 percent)

  • Largest increase of a multi-year deal based on average salary:

Brandon Phillips, whose salary went up 1,556 percent, from $407,500 to an average of $6.75 million under his $27 million, four-year contract. Followed by Robinson Cano, whose salary rose 1,428 percent, from $490,800 to an average of $7.5 million in his $30 million, four-year deal.

For the 48 players that exchanged figures, total amount of salary by position (base salary), along with player that had highest salary for that position:

  • SP (8 players): $26,780,000 (Highest: Erik Bedard at $7,000,000)
  • RP (19 players): $40,272,500 (Highest: Francisco Rodriguez at $10,000,000)
  • 1B (2 players): $13,000,000 (Highest: Ryan Howard at $10,000,000)
  • 2B (5 players): $13,500,000 (Highest: Robinson Cano at $3,000,000)
  • 3B (2 players): $10,487,500 (Highest: Casey Blake at $6,100,000)
  • C (2 players): $3,987,500 (Highest: Josh Bard at $2,237,500)
  • OF (6 players): $16,397,500 (Highest: Michael Cuddyer at $5,000,000)
  • SS (4 players): $11,850,000 (Highest: Felipe Lopez at $4,900,000)

For the 48 players that exchanged figures, total amount of salary by service time (base salary):

  • Under 3 years (6 players): $22,062,500 (Highest: Ryan Howard at $10,000,000)
  • 3-4 years (22 players): $37,815,000 (Highest: Garrett Atkins at $4,387,500)
  • 4-5 years (9 players): $31,322,500 (Highest: Erik Bedard at $7,000,000)
  • 5-6 years (9 players): $40,675,000 (Highest: Francisco Rodriguez at $10,000,000)
  • Above 6 years (1 player): $2,750,000 (Mark Loretta, 12.011 of service time)

The 48 players that exchanged figures, by club:

  • Atlanta (1): Soriano
  • Baltimore (1): Cabrera 
  • Boston (2): Snyder, Youkilis
  • Chicago Cubs (1): Wuertz
  • Cincinnati (2): Belisle, Phillips
  • Cleveland (2): Betancourt, Blake
  • Colorado (3): Atkins, Fuentes, Hawpe
  • Houston (4): Borkowski, Geary, Loretta, Valverde
  • Kansas City (3): German, Greinke, Teahen
  • Los Angeles Dodgers (2): Beimel, Proctor
  • Los Angeles Angels (1): Rodriguez
  • Milwaukee (2): Bush, Hardy
  • Minnesota (2): Cuddyer, Guerrier
  • New York Mets (5): Chavez, Church, Feliciano, Perez, Sosa
  • New York Yankees (3): Bruney, Cano, Wang
  • Oakland (1): Gaudin
  • Philadelphia (2): Bruntlett, Howard
  • Pittsburgh (1): Sanchez
  • San Diego (2): Bard, Greene
  • San Francisco (2): Chulk, Correia 
  • Seattle (1): Bedard
  • St. Louis (2): Molina, Wellemeyer
  • Toronto (1): Rios
  • Washington (2): Lopez, Rauch 

“What’s to like about it?”

To place the arbitration process in perspective, there is a reason that so few clubs and players go all the way to hearing. The stakes are too high. That and the clubs really lose even when they win. Whether a deal is struck before hearing, or if a club wins at hearing, the player nearly always gets a hefty raise.

Case in point, of the 48 players that exchanged figures, all of them but two sees raises this coming season when looking at just base salary. The exceptions are SS Mark Loretta, who lost his salary arbitration hearing with the Astros, and Alex Rios, who signed a one year deal with the Blue Jays. In Loretta’s case, there are no other figures that go with. He lost the case, and gets the salary. In Rios’ case, his base salary might be lower than he made last season, but he gets a $3.5 million signing bonus to go along with his salary of $1,335,000, and he would make an additional $15,000 if he is selected for the All-Star game. So, Rios is guaranteed $4,835,000 this year, an increase of $2,300,000 from last season.

So, it’s understandable that general managers aren’t exactly keen on the process. Asked to comment off the record, here’s what some had to say.

“It’s a way of life, but that doesn’t mean I have to like it,” said one “The player wins, even if we win. And even then, the process of hearings can build tension between us and the player.” Maybe, this reply said it all: “Honestly? What’s to like about it?”

So, is it any wonder that the parties work to get a deal done in advance of going to hearing? At least then they might be able to save a smidgen of the owner’s money.

The Mid-Point

Comparing the offer figure by the club and the requested figure by the player, we can derive the mid-point in-between what the club thinks the player is worth, and what the player and agent think he is worth. Of the 48 players that exchanged figures with their clubs, five of them reached base-salary deals for 2008 at this mid-point:

  • Garrett Atkins (Rockies): $4,387,500
  • Erik Bedard (Mariners after trade from Orioles): $7,000,000
  • Joe Beimel (Dodgers): $1,925,000
  • Kevin Correia (Giants): $1,075,000
  • Matt Guerrier (Twins): $950,000

As mentioned, the vast majority of players will receive a salary below the mid-point in-between the offered and requested salaries. Some, however, will receive salaries above the mid-point. Those seven players are:

  • Josh Bard (Padres): $2,237,500, or $62,500 (2.79 percent) above the mid-point ($2,175,000)  
  • Eric Bruntlett (Phillies): $800,000, or $125,000 (15.63 percent) above the mid-point ($675,000)
  • Geoff Geary (Astros): $1,125,000 or $25,000 (2.22 percent) above the mid-point ($1,100,000)
  • Khalil Green (Padres): $4,500,000 or $50,000 (1.11 percent) above the mid-point ($4,450,000)
  • Ryan Howard (Phillies): $10,000,000 or $1,500,000 (15 percent) above the mid-point ($8,500,000). Note: Howard won his salary arbitration hearing with the Phillies.
  • Oliver Perez (Mets): $6,500,000 or $887,500 (13.65 percent) above the mid-point ($5,612,500). Note: Perez won his salary arbitration hearing with the Mets.
  • Scott Proctor (Dodgers): $1,150,000 or $35,000 (3.04 percent) above the mid-point ($1,115,000).

The rest of the players that exchanged figures (35), reached deals that were below the mid-point, which explains why clubs work to reach the deals in advance of hearing, knowing that they could lose their case.

The following is a listing of players that had the largest decrease in salary when compared to the mid-point (base salary, no bonuses included):

  • Alex Rios (Blue Jays): $3,757,500 below the mid-point ($5,092,500) or -73.78 percent.
  • J.J. Hardy (Brewers): $1,075,000 below the mid-point ($2,725,000) or -39.45 percent.
  • Mark Loretta (Astros): $1,075,000 below the mid-point ($3,825,000) or -28.10 percent.
  • Yadier Molina (Cardinals): $550,000 below the mid-point ($2,300,000) or -23.91 percent.

Remember, Molina reached a 4-year deal that will see him earning an average salary of $3,625,000 over the life of his contract with the Cardinals, so the decline in salary this year will be made up in subsequent years ($3.25M in 2009, $4.24M in 2010, and $5.25M in 2010).

As for Loretta, his decrease is based in losing in salary arbitration.

What Can We Learn From the Hearings?

 This year will most likely be remembered for the Ryan Howard ruling. Howard beat the Phillies in arbitration, which was a feat unto itself. Consider, the following:

  • The Phillies had been 7-0 in salary arbitration up to the Howard case (Jerry Koosman, Alan Knicely, Kevin Gross, Dickie Thon, Dale Sveum, Willie Banks and Travis Lee). The last case the Phillies won was 2001 with Travis Lee.
  • Tal Smith, who has represented nearly every club in his long tenure as a representative for management, was representing the Phillies.
  • The gap between offering figure ($7,000,000) and requesting figure ($10,000,000) was the largest gap between the sides for the 2008 class that exchanged figures.
  • Howard’s requesting figure was the highest ever for a player with his level of service time, under 3 years (2.145).

With Howard’s win, he becomes the player with the highest winning award figure since Andruw Jones won his case with the Braves in 2001 ($8,200,000) and ties for the all-time award with Alfonso Soriano who lost his case with the Nationals in 2006 (he had requested $12,000,000). In winning, he sets the bar exceptionally high for young players (under 3 years of ST), or Super Twos.

Other factoids:

  • There were 8 hearings this year, with the owners winning 6-2. The last time there was that many players that went to hearing was 2001 when 14 players had their cases heard.
  • While Howard’s gap between offering and requesting figures seems high ($3 million), it isn’t the largest. The $4,475,000 gap between the Cubs offering figure ($11,025,000) and Carlos Zambrano requested figure ($15,500,000) last year is the largest gap ever. 

Conclusions

The owners have beaten the players in salary arbitration for 12 consecutive years, but players still enjoy incredible salary increases through the arbitration process. The last time the players won was in 1996 when Steve Avery (Braves), Jeff Fassero (Expos), Chuck Knoblauch (Twins), Mark Lewis (Tigers), Mike Stanton (Red Sox), Rick Wilkins (Astros), and Bernie Williams (Yankees) took 7 of the 10 cases heard. With Ryan Howard winning his hearing this year, he sets the table for other young players that enter salary arbitration, raising the bar exceptionally high.

Clubs are wrapping up players earlier and earlier, in many instances through the some of their free agency years. The best example of this was the unprecedented deal the Rockies gave to shortstop Troy Tulowitzki, a six-year, $31 million contract. It was the largest contract awarded to a player with under 2 years of service time (1.033). Dan O’Dowd and the Monforts clearly see the investment in the players that got them into the World Series last season as cornerstones to build off of. But, the question is, did his deal set a bad precedent? As one high-ranking executive said, “Tulowitzki appears to be special and his signing to a multi-year contract at this stage may very well work out to be of benefit to the Rockies.  But, frankly I would have waited. He wasn't even arbitration eligible until 2010.”

The landscape with free agency and arbitration has altered the face of Major League Baseball forever since they were instituted in the early ‘70s. But, as I have outlined, it is clearly salary arbitration that increases the size of the players’ wallets more than free agency. In that, salary arbitration should be seen as Marvin Miller’s pride and joy.

Select the image above to see details of the 48 players that exchanged figures with their clubs, agents (where they could be found) along with contract information. Please contact Maury Brown to fill in gaps in the agent register

Media and clubs can contact Maury Brown for an even further detailed accounting of these players, as well.

Sources: The Biz of Baseball's historical arbitration research, The AP, Jayson Stark


Maury Brown

Maury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is also a contributor to Baseball Prospectus, and is available as a freelance writer.

Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?