best business credit card for travel rewards how to increase credit card limit icici best cashback credit card malaysia 2013 reduce credit card debt calculator usa payday cash advance calculate credit card interest on balance natwest credit card fraud phone anz low rate credit card apply how to get credit card company to increase limit get a home loan with bad credit rating free online loan calculator is credit card interest tax deductible 2013 credit card account for small business citibank no credit credit card bmo cashback credit card secure credit card bank of america canada credit card promotions best no fee credit card canada 2012 hello kitty credit card uk credit card logos square how do business cash advances work get a visa credit card online sbi credit cards application status how to use a credit card machine without a phone line hbc credit card points credit card verification number visa who has the best cash rewards credit card how old do you have to be to sign up for credit card should i pay off my high interest credit cards first hdfc credit card offer direct payday lenders no teletrack only oprah how to get out of credit card debt chase freedom credit card benefits compare balance transfer credit cards australia online application for credit cards wireless credit card terminal singapore average household credit card debt us same day online cash advance in south africa credit card online apply india standard chartered credit card customer care number india free online credit card generator software halifax credit card login online mastercard exchange rate tool not working pay best buy credit card hrs student credit card comparison uk test credit card numbers that will decline apple store ipod credit card scanner best credit card processing for small business best fast cash loans nordstrom credit card visa signature veterans business loans with bad credit cash advance ukiah ca review bank of america cash rewards credit cards virgin credit card minimum payment what is the best credit card to have yahoo answers valero comcreditcard login virtual technology to compare credit card merchant accounts low interest payday loans no credit check malaysia best credit card offer 2013 request credit card rate reduction valid credit card numbers with cvv and expiration date and name credit card application form hdfc bank pay walmart credit card credit card chase student credit card requirements walmart credit card number phone unsecured credit card debt after death amazon uk credit card security credit card online application ireland ace cash advance memphis tn first time home loans with bad credit chase credit card fees international transactions best hotel reward credit cards 2011 online credit card fraud indonesia hsbc costco credit card payment credit card transfer deals nz lowest flat rate credit card processing corporate credit card credit score how to get cash from a walmart visa gift card sbi credit card settlement process lowest apr credit card cheapest credit card rates in ireland cibc credit card insurance best credit cards rewards program best small business credit card with travel rewards us airways credit card comparison when are chase credit card payments due best buy credit card login payment best travel credit card canada 2011 new debit visa card canada credit cards with airline miles for fair credit compare charity credit cards uk alaska airlines credit card usa orchard bank credit card good or bad heartland credit card processing contact apply for ge credit card online international credit cards in india best visa card rewards chase bank credit card loans chase credit card minimum payment interest my virgin credit card payment shop online prepaid credit card a3 black card uk chase credit card usa punishment for credit card fraud uk student credit cards instant approval credit cards deals for balance transfers best travel credit cards for students pay advance loans hdfc credit card reward points expire credit rating agencies credit card visa generator 2012 apply for a mastercard canada best buy master credit card payment citi american airlines credit card reviews credit card prepaid uk credit card debt relief company reviews mbna cash back credit card review icici credit card interest rate calculator amazon credit card payment applying for a credit card with no credit score pnb online credit cards apply credit card apply online in india black card visa stainless steel student no interest credit cards free credit card number and cvv code 2013 credit card authorization form wording low interest rate credit card balance transfer electronic stores that offer credit cards new payday loan lenders online student credit card barclays credit expert score secured credit cards to rebuild bad credit costco merchant credit card processing reviews capital one credit card cash advance pin usaa secured credit card virtual us credit card with us address credit card offers with 0 balance transfer fees unsecured credit card with bad credit go compare credit card sears secure credit card login new credit cards for poor credit list of valid credit card numbers 2012 go compare credit card balance transfers best balance transfer credit cards for good credit hdfc credit card helpline indore online visa card best credits cards chase marriott rewards credit card benefits icici credit card helpline india virtual credit card terminal no monthly fees tesco credit card points worth credit card debt consolidation loan chase prepaid credit cards travelling abroad how many credit cards can i sign up for natwest student credit card increase limit best buy credit card credit check walmart credit cards online account do i need a credit card to check into a hotel chase freedom credit card international fees natwest credit card protection purchases walmart credit card no interest for 24 months how to pay my hdfc credit card payment online instant paypal virtual credit card priceline rewards visa card customer service lowes credit card approval odds discover credit card phone number ge money bank credit card list does usaa credit card have foreign transaction fee is it worth getting a disney credit card capital one virtual credit card number standard chartered platinum credit card apply online lowest rate credit cards 2012 citibank pre approved credit card credit card interest free period australia free credit card terminal software credit card limit increase without permission credit cards for low income good credit chase secured credit card pay citibank corporate credit card bill online citibank corporate credit card statement credit card fraud protection law cimb credit card application form singapore bad credit loans direct lenders canada visa credit card number 2013 chase disney credit card status credit card review singapore cancel virgin credit card online capital one secured visa credit cards obama credit card debt relief program natwest credit card protection plan barclay credit card toll free number international prepaid credit cards usa credit card debt on death uk government travel credit card training credit card applications pdf update credit card associated with apple id zurich credit card insurance cba how to get a nandos black card orange prepaid credit card compare business credit cards australia credit card transfer offers nz advance payday loans in richmond va forbes top credit cards 2013 hdfc credit cards rewards points redemption bad credit loan instant decision online best credit card company philippines business loans with bad credit south africa tesco credit card balance transfer promotional code 2012 analysis on credit card fraud detection methods ieee paper how much does quickbooks credit card processing cost easy to get low limit credit cards accept all major credit cards mastercard credit cards for students icici coral credit card apply online credit card fraud statistics in malaysia visa card generator with cvv best american airlines credit card signup bonus dave ramsey reducing credit card debt united credit card free baggage iphone credit card payment system citibank cash back credit card malaysia anz platinum card travel insurance nz rbs student credit card interest rates average credit card interest rate hdfc credit card payment online from other bank account credit card processing fees lawsuit federal programs for credit card debt relief unsecured credit cards to rebuild bad credit need for speed carbon reward cards guide buy international visa gift card online costco business credit card application which credit card is best in india 2012 credit card scanner for android phone bad credit car finance birmingham discover credit card login payment how do i calculate credit card minimum payment usaa secured credit card after bankruptcy icici credit card charges unsecured credit cards for bad credit in canada best credit card debt consolidation companies hdfc credit card online apply british airways credit card deals standard bank british airways credit card send money online using discover credit card good credit card apr rates what is the best credit card rate available mastercard credit card exchange rate what is a secured credit card to rebuild credit disputing unauthorized credit card charges chase freedom credit limit increase request what is the best no fee credit card in canada marriott rewards premier credit card from chase review virgin atlantic credit cards login guaranteed credit card canada bad credit international travel tips credit cards standard chartered credit card online payment india free mobile credit card processing terminal hsbc household credit card login generate us credit card number easiest store credit card to get 2013 lost credit card bank of ireland cash reward credit cards india merchant credit card fees wiki credit card comparison site au everyday rewards cards registration lost target visa card compare personal loans bad credit ppi credit card calculator american express platinum card benefits regus travel credit cards compare canada how to get a low interest credit card with bad credit credit card protection insurance claims anz visa credit cards australia quick online loans sa free high risk credit cards best small business credit cards 2011 visa debit cards with no fees list of payday loan lenders uk app for credit card payments on iphone unsecured credit card debt default credit card number location mastercard the best credit cards in canada most popular credit cards in canada will a secured credit card help bad credit credit card reward program comparison canada credit card debt relief citibank balance transfer offer best credit card for college students with no credit history best credit cards no annual fees rewards discover credit card reviews 2013 tesco clubcard credit card air miles credit card low interest balance transfer can i pay my bestbuy credit card with a gift card no credit credit cards chase new credit card rules 2012 mastercard credit card for bad credit how do banks make money from credit card companies payday lenders uk 2012 credit card debt consolidation loans usa aadvantage credit card 50000 what is a credit card number that works us bank credit card login hsbc business credit cards uk ocbc credit card application form standard chartered credit card online payment login fast payday loan no credit check bank of america credit card 5 cash back american express secured credit card canada credit card cashback bonus offer lowest interest credit cards canada visa credit card application form free list of valid credit card numbers pay amazon visa card online fake credit card numbers that work 3 major credit card companies how to get a us credit card living in canada walmart credit card cash back rewards interest free credit cards marks and spencer standard chartered credit card payment through credit card best australian travel credit card same day pay loans no credit checks post office platinum card credit limit mobile credit card processing canada reviews city bank credit card apply india prepaid credit card to build credit score american airlines aadvantage credit card 50000 high cash back credit card canada how long does it take to get credit card bill payday advance loans online payday lenders direct lenders secured citibank credit cards best no annual fee credit cards 2012 credit card processing fees quickbooks how to get an american express secured credit card guaranteed approval credit cards for bad credit canada best air travel reward credit card canada cash back credit cards 2011 how to increase credit card limit 12 months interest free credit cards australia credit card with no annual fee for bad credit find lowest apr credit card iphone credit card app uk free credit card scanner bank of america credit card application instant decision pay bank of america credit card bill online signature visa cards online credit card application philippines ofw visa low interest credit cards hsbc credit card offers uk how to increase credit card limit lloyds tsb best student credit cards 2013 gander mountain master credit card login lowest rate credit card nz apply online for credit card sbi bank credit card account number font check status of costco credit card application using nationwide credit card abroad getting a credit card with bad credit canada tesco bank 0 credit card top bad credit loan lenders bank of america credit card low apr what is a bad credit score for employment capital one visa card for bad credit how to remove credit card info from apple id vodafone balance transfer chennai virgin credit card balance transfer australia best deal on credit card gift cards apply online credit card natwest tesco credit card online uk bad credit card debt business credit card no interest balance transfers fha bad credit loan reviews travel credit card no international fees toys r us gold card coupons ge money credit card list will my chase credit card work in canada natwest student credit card after graduation get credit card online free capital one credit card company complaints how to make cash advance in bpi credit card credit card balance transfer calculator natwest credit card protection refund credit card over limit fees law high risk credit cards uk hdfc credit card charges for lic premium payment virtual credit card number mastercard loans for bad credit online instant decision rbs credit card services telephone top travel credit cards canada best credit card rate us money saving expert credit card repayment calculator pay myer visa card online jp morgan chase credit card services commonwealth bank credit card comparison hsbc premier credit card benefits capital one bank secured credit card teachers credit union credit cards what kind of credit card can i get with fair credit canada credit cards rewards best best credit card for balance transfers uk jcpenney credit card pay my bill prepaid credit cards visa numbers 5 cash back reward credit cards fnb credit card repayment calculator no credit check payday loans no brokers capital one credit card login to pay bill barclaycard platinum credit card uk td emerald visa cardholder agreement tesco credit card points on balance transfers how to get a personal loan with bad credit in india marriott rewards premier credit card online credit card merchants for small business want to apply for credit card with bad credit credit score matters best international travel credit card bank of america credit card cash advance limit guaranteed credit cards for no credit visa debit cards bank of ireland chase increase credit limit hard pull small business credit card processing services credit card verification form (ccvf) apply for sears credit card hsbc credit card settlement process chase visa cards with rewards best rate credit card balance transfer lowest interest rate credit card singapore compare all airline credit cards chase student credit card offers best pay as you go credit card cdyne credit card verification web service quickbooks credit card processing kit direct payday lenders online uk hdfc virtual credit card emi intuit gopayment credit card terminal capital one credit card no interest rate get a personal loan with bad credit online best reloadable prepaid credit cards standard bank online application for credit card no credit check credit cards no security deposit 6 best credit cards for bad credit credit card payment planner how do you apply for a credit card yahoo cash advance payday loans columbus ohio how to apply for hsbc classic credit card college student credit cards no credit history stores that offer credit cards for no credit free credit check uk no credit card visa card ukraine delta credit card cash back delta skymiles? credit card companion ticket best balance transfer credit card no fee quick cash loans no fees best credit card offers for students best credit cards for poor credit rating usaa secured credit card graduate 3 most popular credit cards credit card apps for iphone reviews best travel reward credit cards 2011 reclaim credit card charges calculator credit score needed for toys r us credit card walmart credit card score requirement citibank credit card application form disney credit card designs best credit cards for balance transfers no fee standard chartered credit card points redemption singapore hyatt credit card offer 2013 credit card number generator 2013 credit cards instant approval good credit credit card applications online instant approvals hsbc credit card customer care toll free number bangalore what credit card is best for me quiz city bank credit card application tracking india long term bad credit loans australia prepaid credit card visa santander 0 credit card existing customers pay my capital 1 credit card bill cash back credit cards canada comparison good visa credit cards for students capital 1 credit card login cheapest way to accept credit cards by phone sbi international credit card charges o2 prepaid credit card uk government credit card debt relief canada barclays bank credit card sign in what do i need to know when applying for a credit card bank of america credit card promotions 2013 credit card uk no credit history post office credit card contact telephone number loans for bad credit no fees top credit card companies 2012 merchant cash advances uk i want to sign up for a credit card credit cards with gas and grocery rewards where can i get a personal loan online with bad credit best american airlines credit card offers 2011 best credit cards to use abroad 2013 td bank visa gift card login best reward credit cards 2011 money magazine visa credit card numbers that work with cvv2 accept credit cards online uk
Home All Articles By the Numbers: Owners Now 5-0 in Salary Arbitration

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1357 guests online

Atom RSS

By the Numbers: Owners Now 5-0 in Salary Arbitration PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 2
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Maury Brown   
Wednesday, 20 February 2008 10:20

 

Money and Baseball

 

A Look at How the Salary Arbitration Process Functions in Major League Baseball 

At this rate, the owners/clubs are on pace to set a record for their ability to win salary arbitration cases against the players, by way of hearing, than any point in history.

In five arbitration hearings, the clubs are still batting 1.000. Score? Owners 5, Players 0.

Yesterday saw SS Mark Loretta losing to the Astros, thereby guaranteeing a 12th consecutive year that management has won the salary arbitration battle. The last time the players won was 1996 when 10 cases were heard, with the players winning 7 to 3. The following is a breakdown of those that won that year:

  • Steve Avery (Braves) – Requested: $4.2M, Offered: $3.6M
  • Jeff Fassero (Expos) – Requested: $2.8M, Offered: $2M
  • Chuck Knoblauch (Twins) – Requested: $4.67M, Offered: $3.75M
  • Mark Lewis (Tigers) – Requested: $670K, Offered: $450K
  • Mike Stanton (Red Sox) – Requested: $1.75M, Offered: $1.2M
  • Rick Wilkins (Astros) – Requested: $1.55M, Offered: $1.25M
  • Bernie Williams (Yankees) – Requested: $3M, Offered: $2.555M

To date, management has won 279 cases to the players 203

(See the complete historical scorecard for MLB salary arbitration)

Today sees Ryan Howard go to hearing with the Phillies. The gap between club figure and player figure in this case ($3 million) represents the largest gap between figures for the salary arbitration class of 2008.

This past Saturday, Scott Lauber, who covers the Phillies, ran the first of three installments on the arbitration process for the Delaware News Journal, and asked me to comment about it.

Select Read More to see the rest of this analysis on salary arbitration

As reported on 2/16:

There are no indications that the Phillies are nearing an accord with Casey Close, Howard's Beverly Hills-based agent. So, barring an 11th-hour settlement next week, Howard's salary will be decided after a three-person panel of arbitrators listens to arguments from each side. And an army of Phillies fans, disguised as amateur psychologists, are wary of the effect a hearing may have on Howard's psyche.

"I don't care who you are, if your employer says that you aren't good at something, it's not going to be an enjoyable experience," said Maury Brown, a sports business analyst and founder of the Business of Sports Network.

[…]

Brown, who studies and tracks arbitration cases, said hearings can become so unpleasant that many settlements occur literally at the last minute, as the player, agent and team officials are walking into the room for the hearing.

Howard and the Phillies still may work out a one-year or multiyear contract. But it's believed that Howard and his family have asked for a richer deal than the seven-year, $85 million extension the Phillies gave to All-Star second baseman Chase Utley before last season. And the sides' $3 million difference of opinion over a 2008 salary is the largest of any player who filed for arbitration this year.

"That's not pocket change," Brown said. "Three million dollars is a decent middle reliever."

To clarify my statements, management isn’t really saying players “aren't good at something,” but rather saying they're not worth as much as the player is requesting. The player and his agent see the situation differently, of course, if matters have gotten to the stage of going all the way to hearing without reaching a contract agreement. Most often, agreements are reached beforehand due to the economics of the situation, rather than the unpleasant nature of the salary arbitration process. Like I said in the case of Howard, $3 million isn’t exactly chump change. Both sides have a lot to lose, depending on the outcome of the ruling by the arbitration panel.

Lauber then followed up with a blog posting on The News Journal, in which he adds:

Historically, owners have won 278 of 481 hearings (57.8 percent). But according to Maury Brown, a sports business analyst and founder of the Business of Sports Network, the owners never really win. Talked to Brown by phone yesterday, and he made the valid point that players get enormous raises even when they lose a hearing. For example, Wang made $489,500 last season. He will make $4 million in 2008.

This was, of course, posted before Loretta lost his case yesterday with the Astros, changing the overall scorecard to owners winning 279 of 482 cases (57.88 percent). In terms of the players winning even when losing, let’s look at the amounts that players that lost salary arbitration hearings this year were making last season, and what they will now make after “losing”. All of these players will gain significant amounts of cash compared to last season, with Mark Lorretta the exception. In his case, he’s going to make less than last season.

  • Felipe Lopez: Last season $3,900,000 Club figure: $4,900,000 – Raise (’08 salary): $1,000,000
  • Chien-Ming Wang: Last season $489,500 Club figure: $4,000,000 – Raise (’08 salary): $3,510,500
  • Jose Valverde: Last season $489,500 Club figure: $2,000,000 – Raise (’08 salary): $1,510,500
  • Brian Fuentes: Last season $3,525,000 Club figure: $5,050,000 – Raise (’08 salary): $1,525,000
  • Mark Lorretta: Last season $3,500,000 Club figure: $2,750,000 – Decrease from last season (’08 salary): $ 750,000

To add yet another article by Lauber, he followed up with an article Monday regarding the arbitration process, citing veteran Tom Gordon, who is now a reliever for Phillies:

Gordon recalled the Royals brought a representative to make their argument, so the negatives didn't come directly from a front-office member. It is likely the Phillies will do the same, especially after enlisting arbitration guru Tal Smith to help prepare their case.

Smith, a longtime Astros executive, has worked on more than 150 cases (he beat Barry Bonds twice in the '90s), and is known for his soft touch at the arbitration table. He often is able to state a case without getting too personal.

"I can only recall two or three [cases] where I thought there was any animosity," Smith said in a 2005 interview with Business of Sports Network. "To me, it's nothing more than an ongoing discussion or debate, the same as you would have in negotiations, except for the fact that it's being presented to a third party. It's not like you have to be derisive or castigate the player. I mean, the numbers are the numbers."

Maury Brown, a sports business analyst, said the arguments typically aren't bogged down by advanced baseball statistics. The Phillies won't dazzle the panel with Howard's "range factor." The arbitrators are selected by Major League Baseball and the players' association, and although Brown said they understand baseball, they hardly qualify as sabermetricians.

On the latter of my comments, it is this factor which brings in matters such as comparing salary figures and a player’s service time. For example, the Yankees made their case with Chien-Ming Wang  based, in part, on the fact that their offering figure was the highest arbitration figure ever for a pitcher with the amount of service time that Wang has (2.159 years). So, it is not all about player statistics, but rather a comparative process in which the amount of the salary figures can play a large part in which figure (player, or owner) is selected.

The psychology of the process is debatable. I would suggest that most players understand that salary arbitration is all part of the business, yet at the same time, feel a twinge of negativity when their employer (management) makes a case that they aren’t worth what the player is asking. After all, athletes at this level have been coddled and told that they are star material, many times, since they took up sports. The process goes straight to their egos. Somehow, I imagine, that with the majority of these players getting ready to enjoy substantial salary increases in their “loses”, the extra green will somehow lessen the blow to their egos.


Maury Brown

Maury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is also an author for Baseball Prospectus, Basketball Prospectus and is an available as a freelance writer.

Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?