halifax credit card balance transfer promo code credit card fraud alert 2012 halifax credit card ppi claim success best credit card cashback singapore top 100 credit card processors payday lenders direct lenders td cash back visa card bad credit auto loan reviews consumer finance college students and credit cards abn amro netherlands credit card online how to make a balance transfer credit card natwest free visa gift cards what;s the best usaa credit card statute of limitations for disputing credit card charges virtual credit cards to verify paypal report credit card fraud online payday loans no credit check instant approval pay my toys r us credit card online how often can i apply for citi credit cards nz balance transfer credit card deals credit card debt calculator template list of credit card companies for bad credit delta skymiles credit card offers what is the best cashback credit card with no annual fee santander 123 credit card cash back list mastercard gold credit card travel insurance online application for credit card citibank natwest black credit card terms and conditions major bank secured credit cards secured credit card bad credit canada free visa card generator highest credit card limit possible american express gold card money saving expert natwest black card login want to apply for hdfc credit card online what;s the best cashback credit card where can i use my horizon credit card capital one applying for credit card easy to get credit cards with poor credit canada alaska airline credit card deals applying for a business credit card with bad credit department store credit cards canada paypal credit card fees canada get a credit card instantly hdfc indigo offer credit card what is the best credit card for me does discover have a secured credit card current lowes credit card promotions instant payday loans vanquis credit card reviews online loan companies canada canada credit card debt ways to prevent credit card fraud online student credit cards visa mastercard metal business card chase /credit card holder discovery platinum credit card benefits hsbc 0 credit card offers low interest credit card offers australia rate of interest on cash withdrawal from credit card hdfc compare sbi and hdfc credit card best student credit card scotiabank scene visa online payday loans direct lender instant approval halifax clarity credit card cash back how to choose a credit card singapore sbi credit card statement can you get cashback on credit card purchases chase credit card with miles rewards mbna 0 balance transfer credit cards chase credit cards login best buy credit card payment on phone icici international credit card charges united mileage plus credit card phone number canadian prepaid reloadable credit cards applying for credit cards hurt credit score travel credit cards review visa credit cards with low interest capital one ventureone sm rewards credit card reviews australian no credit check credit cards bank of america credit card machine customer service hdfc bank diners club international credit card free credit card numbers that work with security code and expiration date 2013 how to get a 5 000 loan with bad credit getting a secured credit card bank of america capital one credit card insurance cover what bank will give me a credit card with bad credit in australia rebuild credit cards secured most secure credit card reader how do i pay my firestone credit card online 10 000 credit card debt relief canada zero interest credit card offers for 12 months what is a secured credit card mean sample visa credit card number aqua credit card mobile app chase visa credit card benefits types of credit card fraud can you pay sears credit card with a gift card apply for american express corporate credit card fake visa card security code go mastercard australia payday loan companies online no credit check best rate credit cards uk do they sell prepaid credit cards walgreens how to pay off my credit card debt fast sears credit card customer service hsbc how to redeem hdfc world credit card reward points company credit card anz low rate credit card cash advance credit cards 0 interest on balance transfers payday cash advance loans rewards credit card reviews 2012 intuit credit card processing credit cards for fair credit discover best 0 percent interest credit cards pay national city credit card apply for goodyear credit card hsbc credit card application retrieval air canada credit card charges american first cash advance visa debit cards online shopping best unsecured credit card with bad credit blank credit card authorization form template best no annual fee credit cards australia can i use bestbuy gift cards to pay off credit card compare hdfc gold and titanium credit cards accept credit card payments on iphone uk can get walmart credit card bad credit santander credit card 0 13 months no fee free secured credit cards for bad credit bad credit loans online no brokers western union gold card uk cibc credit cards aeroplan sears credit card application reference number walmart store card credit score best credit card offers for students 2012 free ipad credit card reader uk what;s the best small business credit card best credit card for students barclay credit card app status hudson bay company lost credit card low interest transfer balance credit cards shell gas credit card canada credit card limit calculator online foursquare credit card processing app best cashback credit cards uae chase credit card rewards login best cashback credit card in india 2011 best canadian credit card to use in usa visa card issue number location interest free credit card uk visa cards start with what digits international credit card icici bank tesco bank 0 credit card cnn best credit cards bad credit apply for visa student credit card capital one credit card limit increase standard chartered new credit card apply barclays credit card eligibility checker tata sbi credit card apply online how to pay barclays credit card payment newest payday lenders uk cash payday loans no credit check complaints about first premier credit cards city bank credit card customer care phone number delhi american express delta skymiles credit card login credit rebuilding credit cards canada best credit card for travel to south america best credit card to have 2013 capital one credit card for students with no credit free credit card with bad credit history uk credit card debt 2012 can you use prepaid credit cards in usa need a credit card fast with bad credit in south africa us bank credit card payment options unfair credit card fees uk barclays visa black card free credit card scanner for android fast cash loans with bad credit online hsbc platinum credit card travel insurance uk the best islamic credit card in malaysia best credit cards for bad credit canada ge money bank credit card services pay advance loans raleigh nc walmart discover credit card cash advance walmart credit card canada phone number mastercard debit card anz where can i use my bp gas credit card mastercard cash plus reviews credit cards for very bad credit with no deposit how to get a nandos black card ebay sbi credit card helpline number wells fargo credit card rewards mortgage credit card interest rates malaysia business credit card comparison 2012 ge capital lowes credit card phone number pc credit card processing major credit card companies wiki gnc gold card renewal i have no credit what credit card should i get ikea credit card apply malaysia hbc credit card contact number best travel credit cards in india credit card scanner for computer payday cash advances no faxing same day payday loans direct lenders barclays credit card login uae how to redeem citibank indian oil credit card reward points prepaid mastercard uk free virtual paypal credit card credit card number visa or mastercard free master credit card numbers usa credit card numbers is it easy to get a walmart credit card canadian visa credit card application apply for credit union credit cards discuss the cost of accepting credit cards sbi credit card customer care number in noida credit cards for recently discharged bankruptcy top credit cards in india 2013 guaranteed unsecured credit cards bodog credit card verification agreement wells fargo credit card transfer fee best credit cards for balance transfers no fee platinum credit card bank of ireland credit card instant approval no annual fee how to use black cardamom cash back offer credit cards india bank of america corporate credit card programs capital one credit card uk cash advance loans direct lenders only marriott rewards chase credit card online hdfc credit card customer care phone number bangalore balance transfer offers for bad credit zero percent balance transfer credit card offers credit card 0 apr starwood hotel credit card review small business credit card offers for poor credit cheap interest payday loans online device for iphone credit card payment can i get a credit card with bad credit history best secured credit card bad credit opt out of credit card offers website nationwide visa credit card protection how to get student credit cards with no credit how to get a car loan with bad credit and no cosigner generate valid credit card number verifone wireless credit card machines american express types of credit cards verifone credit card machine zero interest balance transfer credit cards canada get credit card with bad credit australia online credit card apr calculator 12 month loan bad credit no guarantor prepaid credit card paypal uk daily credit card interest calculator gold card national rail discount paypal sandbox sample credit card number capital one platinum card credit limit pay old navy credit card visa best credit cards for no credit 2013 easy approval credit cards virtual credit card paypal free credit card reward comparison calculator best credit cards uk rewards target red card visa application how do you calculate interest payments on a credit card store credit cards with no credit check major credit card company list add money to paypal prepaid credit card household bank credit card sign in how to get free credit card numbers 2012 how does chase apply credit card payments rci bank of america credit card login how online credit card payment system works 12 month cash loans today td visa cardholder agreement barclaycard cashback credit card terms and conditions money saving expert credit card charges refund chase southwest rapid rewards credit card review get credit card numbers and cvv capital one secured visa credit cards sbi credit card customer care number mumbai low interest credit cards nz how to get a business loan with bad credit and no collateral can i apply for a walmart credit card and use it the same day credit cards with free travel insurance singapore bad credit auto loan calculator best credit cards 2013 for bad credit rebuild how does a credit card work online free credit card details 2013 that work bad credit visa card canada can i get a chase credit card in canada generate us credit card number sample credit card billing authorization form best credit card rewards 2012 us best money back credit cards 2013 free fake visa credit card number citibank credit card insurance travel capital one first credit card virgin 0 balance transfer credit card free prepaid credit card worldwide mastercard prepaid credit cards uk vip cash payday loans typical credit card limits uk what are good credit cards for college students walmart credit card report lost applying for a credit card with a bad credit rating best pay day loans direct lenders corporate credit card programs best practices tesco clubcard credit card for balance transfers guaranteed approval unsecured visa credit card kisan credit card interest rate punjab national bank chase student credit card karma points online cash advance lenders in georgia sbi credit card billdesk malaysia credit card comparison no fee credit cards canada virtual credit card paypal canada credit card fees nab credit card insurance contact credit card name verification service hdfc credit card charges for lic premium payment credit card poor credit rating uk chase visa credit card my account visa platinum credit card offers india sears canada online credit card application best online credit card merchant account hdfc credit card helpline indore is a secured credit card a good idea credit card protection against faulty goods federal bank credit cards india secure credit card canada credit card interest charges explained usaa lost credit card phone number hdfc credit card interest free emi how to get credit card details off itunes amazon credit card bonus offer gold credit card travel insurance commonwealth can you get cashback on a credit card transaction free visa credit card number with csc hdfc credit card a chase credit card login help magnum cash advance payday loan best travel credit card for thailand unsecured visa credit card bad credit can i pay for a money order with a credit card at the post office reward credit cards comparison prepaid credit cards compare uk google wallet credit card security santander 123 cashback credit card annual fee travel no fee credit card capital one aspire travel platinum mastercard credit card fraudsters arrested credit card application online canada sign up for a credit card with no credit anz credit card balance transfer 0 ways to reduce credit card debt faster southwest credit card car rental deals visa credit card for businesses instant approval credit cards hsbc platinum credit card points redemption hsbc best buy credit card reviews low apr credit cards for poor credit virgin credit card ppi reclaim capital one online credit card management need a personal loan with bad credit fast what is a credit card machine used for credit card score canada credit cards for business with fair credit at what age can i apply for a credit card bad credit rebuilding credit cards best credit card deal canada ge credit card login australia hdfc credit card customer care number kerala report lost visa card canada easy money online cash advance what is the easiest store credit card to get approved for fidelity credit cards 2 cash back credit card application rejected india pay jcpenney credit card wells fargo no foreign transaction fee credit card cash back credit cards with no annual fee square iphone credit card app best visa card for international travel help with credit card debt ireland does capital one have a prepaid credit card axis bank credit cards details pay sears credit cards online should i use my tesco credit card abroad shopping rewards cards app chase visa credit card logon hsbc credit card online payment billdesk bank of ireland credit card security services how to get a credit card lloyds low limit credit cards for bad credit neiman marcus credit card services zurich credit card insurance travel idbi bank credit card apply online apply for credit card hsbc bank best credit card debt consolidation services payday loans with guaranteed approval for bad credit chase marriott rewards credit card benefits instant decision business credit cards payday advance uk reviews spg amex credit card offer how do credit cards charge interest on cash advances citi corporate credit card login 4 major credit cards companies barclays credit card lost and stolen pre approved credit cards capital one best travel credit cards 2013 chase freedom credit card payment address royalty free credit card icons westpac altitude credit card travel insurance discover credit cards payment address mastercard prepaid account balance online payday loans instant approval direct lenders no credit check payday online loans no credit check best credit union secured credit cards small business credit cards no credit check hsbc credit card apply now disney credit card reviews 2012 how do i take a cash advance on my capital one credit card hdfc credit cards helpline 0 credit cards with no transfer fee how to get a visa black card multiple credit card payoff calculator best travel credit cards 2012 virgin credit card 0 apr secured business credit card wells fargo compare credit cards for bad credit what is the best credit card to have with no credit unlimited cash back credit card malaysia cibc credit card health insurance pay hdfc credit card online payment blacklisted online payday loans south africa unsecured gas credit cards for bad credit cash advance loans online home how to get a bad credit loan in ireland best credit cards to apply for with low credit total merchant services credit card processing reviews credit card holder ebay india chase visa rewards cards quick bad credit payday loans lord and taylor credit card stolen valid credit card numbers with cvv 2013 citibank credit card information stolen visa credit card number with cvv credit cards with cashback for gas purchases reward credit cards uk 100 day pay loans wells fargo jewelry advantage credit card login prepaid credit card paypal reload how do i apply for a visa credit card online visa credit card no foreign transaction fee credit card companies reporting to irs compare visa and mastercard credit cards online loan lenders uk american express black card travel insurance best credit card app for ipad 2 post office travel credit card what is the best credit card for someone who has bad credit free credit card details with cvv 2013 ann taylor loft credit card customer service free visa card numbers 2013 canada lloyds tsb airmiles credit card contact balance transfer from icici credit card to hdfc icici bank credit card settlement letter citibank gold credit card online apply travel credit cards comparison real valid visa credit card number hdfc bank credit cards eligibility online tracking of credit card application of hdfc bank online loans instant payout barclays visa debit card online banking maxing out credit cards before bankruptcy canada student credit card credit union best buy credit card application employee direct payday loans citibank student credit card australia halifax credit card online application payday loan lenders online credit card limit increase letter easy store credit card for bad credit net pay advance credit card apply online hdfc bank best credit card rates for good credit same day cash loans no bank account where to buy prepaid credit cards in toronto android credit card reader free prepaid credit card generator credit card interest calculator tesco credit card protection plan how do you get a starbucks gold card bank of america visa rewards card balance hdfc credit card payment online from axis bank icici international credit card offers united credit card bonuses say no to 0870 natwest credit card hsbc credit card abroad pre approved credit card canada canada credit card balance transfer
Home All Articles By the Numbers: Owners Now 5-0 in Salary Arbitration

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1055 guests online

Atom RSS

By the Numbers: Owners Now 5-0 in Salary Arbitration PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 2
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Maury Brown   
Wednesday, 20 February 2008 10:20

 

Money and Baseball

 

A Look at How the Salary Arbitration Process Functions in Major League Baseball 

At this rate, the owners/clubs are on pace to set a record for their ability to win salary arbitration cases against the players, by way of hearing, than any point in history.

In five arbitration hearings, the clubs are still batting 1.000. Score? Owners 5, Players 0.

Yesterday saw SS Mark Loretta losing to the Astros, thereby guaranteeing a 12th consecutive year that management has won the salary arbitration battle. The last time the players won was 1996 when 10 cases were heard, with the players winning 7 to 3. The following is a breakdown of those that won that year:

  • Steve Avery (Braves) – Requested: $4.2M, Offered: $3.6M
  • Jeff Fassero (Expos) – Requested: $2.8M, Offered: $2M
  • Chuck Knoblauch (Twins) – Requested: $4.67M, Offered: $3.75M
  • Mark Lewis (Tigers) – Requested: $670K, Offered: $450K
  • Mike Stanton (Red Sox) – Requested: $1.75M, Offered: $1.2M
  • Rick Wilkins (Astros) – Requested: $1.55M, Offered: $1.25M
  • Bernie Williams (Yankees) – Requested: $3M, Offered: $2.555M

To date, management has won 279 cases to the players 203

(See the complete historical scorecard for MLB salary arbitration)

Today sees Ryan Howard go to hearing with the Phillies. The gap between club figure and player figure in this case ($3 million) represents the largest gap between figures for the salary arbitration class of 2008.

This past Saturday, Scott Lauber, who covers the Phillies, ran the first of three installments on the arbitration process for the Delaware News Journal, and asked me to comment about it.

Select Read More to see the rest of this analysis on salary arbitration

As reported on 2/16:

There are no indications that the Phillies are nearing an accord with Casey Close, Howard's Beverly Hills-based agent. So, barring an 11th-hour settlement next week, Howard's salary will be decided after a three-person panel of arbitrators listens to arguments from each side. And an army of Phillies fans, disguised as amateur psychologists, are wary of the effect a hearing may have on Howard's psyche.

"I don't care who you are, if your employer says that you aren't good at something, it's not going to be an enjoyable experience," said Maury Brown, a sports business analyst and founder of the Business of Sports Network.

[…]

Brown, who studies and tracks arbitration cases, said hearings can become so unpleasant that many settlements occur literally at the last minute, as the player, agent and team officials are walking into the room for the hearing.

Howard and the Phillies still may work out a one-year or multiyear contract. But it's believed that Howard and his family have asked for a richer deal than the seven-year, $85 million extension the Phillies gave to All-Star second baseman Chase Utley before last season. And the sides' $3 million difference of opinion over a 2008 salary is the largest of any player who filed for arbitration this year.

"That's not pocket change," Brown said. "Three million dollars is a decent middle reliever."

To clarify my statements, management isn’t really saying players “aren't good at something,” but rather saying they're not worth as much as the player is requesting. The player and his agent see the situation differently, of course, if matters have gotten to the stage of going all the way to hearing without reaching a contract agreement. Most often, agreements are reached beforehand due to the economics of the situation, rather than the unpleasant nature of the salary arbitration process. Like I said in the case of Howard, $3 million isn’t exactly chump change. Both sides have a lot to lose, depending on the outcome of the ruling by the arbitration panel.

Lauber then followed up with a blog posting on The News Journal, in which he adds:

Historically, owners have won 278 of 481 hearings (57.8 percent). But according to Maury Brown, a sports business analyst and founder of the Business of Sports Network, the owners never really win. Talked to Brown by phone yesterday, and he made the valid point that players get enormous raises even when they lose a hearing. For example, Wang made $489,500 last season. He will make $4 million in 2008.

This was, of course, posted before Loretta lost his case yesterday with the Astros, changing the overall scorecard to owners winning 279 of 482 cases (57.88 percent). In terms of the players winning even when losing, let’s look at the amounts that players that lost salary arbitration hearings this year were making last season, and what they will now make after “losing”. All of these players will gain significant amounts of cash compared to last season, with Mark Lorretta the exception. In his case, he’s going to make less than last season.

  • Felipe Lopez: Last season $3,900,000 Club figure: $4,900,000 – Raise (’08 salary): $1,000,000
  • Chien-Ming Wang: Last season $489,500 Club figure: $4,000,000 – Raise (’08 salary): $3,510,500
  • Jose Valverde: Last season $489,500 Club figure: $2,000,000 – Raise (’08 salary): $1,510,500
  • Brian Fuentes: Last season $3,525,000 Club figure: $5,050,000 – Raise (’08 salary): $1,525,000
  • Mark Lorretta: Last season $3,500,000 Club figure: $2,750,000 – Decrease from last season (’08 salary): $ 750,000

To add yet another article by Lauber, he followed up with an article Monday regarding the arbitration process, citing veteran Tom Gordon, who is now a reliever for Phillies:

Gordon recalled the Royals brought a representative to make their argument, so the negatives didn't come directly from a front-office member. It is likely the Phillies will do the same, especially after enlisting arbitration guru Tal Smith to help prepare their case.

Smith, a longtime Astros executive, has worked on more than 150 cases (he beat Barry Bonds twice in the '90s), and is known for his soft touch at the arbitration table. He often is able to state a case without getting too personal.

"I can only recall two or three [cases] where I thought there was any animosity," Smith said in a 2005 interview with Business of Sports Network. "To me, it's nothing more than an ongoing discussion or debate, the same as you would have in negotiations, except for the fact that it's being presented to a third party. It's not like you have to be derisive or castigate the player. I mean, the numbers are the numbers."

Maury Brown, a sports business analyst, said the arguments typically aren't bogged down by advanced baseball statistics. The Phillies won't dazzle the panel with Howard's "range factor." The arbitrators are selected by Major League Baseball and the players' association, and although Brown said they understand baseball, they hardly qualify as sabermetricians.

On the latter of my comments, it is this factor which brings in matters such as comparing salary figures and a player’s service time. For example, the Yankees made their case with Chien-Ming Wang  based, in part, on the fact that their offering figure was the highest arbitration figure ever for a pitcher with the amount of service time that Wang has (2.159 years). So, it is not all about player statistics, but rather a comparative process in which the amount of the salary figures can play a large part in which figure (player, or owner) is selected.

The psychology of the process is debatable. I would suggest that most players understand that salary arbitration is all part of the business, yet at the same time, feel a twinge of negativity when their employer (management) makes a case that they aren’t worth what the player is asking. After all, athletes at this level have been coddled and told that they are star material, many times, since they took up sports. The process goes straight to their egos. Somehow, I imagine, that with the majority of these players getting ready to enjoy substantial salary increases in their “loses”, the extra green will somehow lessen the blow to their egos.


Maury Brown

Maury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is also an author for Baseball Prospectus, Basketball Prospectus and is an available as a freelance writer.

Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?